Gemsny Reviews

Voted Good (5/5)

136 Votes

40 Reviews

Vote Now

In the Jewelry Store category

Pie-Chart Analysis

10% users rated Terrible
0% users rated Poor
0% users rated Average
5% users rated Very Good
85% users rated Excellent
Write a review
D Dona
199 days ago

Unmatched Quality and Service: A Gem of an Experience

I cannot say enough about my exceptional experience with GemsNY. Their team went above and beyond to assist me, ensuring that I found the perfect diamond ring. The diamond itself is truly exquisite, exceeding all my expectations in terms of quality and brilliance. The inclusion of an authentic diamond report and appraisal only added to the confidence and satisfaction I felt as a customer. GemsNY has undoubtedly won my trust and loyalty with their top-notch service and stunning products.
D Dona
199 days ago

Unforgettable Beauty: A Sparkling Journey with GemsNY

Let me take you through my enchanting experience with GemsNY, where dreams truly turn into reality. The team at GemsNY went above and beyond, showering me with their expertise and infinite patience, making every step of my journey a delight. The standout piece of my experience is the breathtaking diamond ring that now adorns my finger, a true masterpiece of exceptional quality that leaves me in awe every time I glance at it. Moreover, the inclusion of an authentic diamond report and a comprehensive appraisal further solidified my confidence in the gem's authenticity and value. Each time the diamond catches the light and sends shimmering reflections all around, I am reminded of the superior craftsmanship and attention to detail that GemsNY prides itself on. This radiant symbol of love and commitment is not just a purchase; it is a cherished memory that I will carry with me forever. Thank you, GemsNY, for transforming my visions into a sparkling reality. Your dedication to excellence has not only left me overjoyed but has also created a bond that will undoubtedly last a lifetime.
J J Coleman
244 days ago

Ruby earrings for 40th anniversary

As my 40th wedding anniversary approached, I set out to find the perfect gift for my wife. I had a vision of surprising her with a stunning pair of ruby earrings, but I couldn't seem to find the exact design I had in mind. That's when I stumbled upon GemsNY, and I am so grateful that I did. From the moment I reached out to them, the team at GemsNY went above and beyond to bring my vision to life. Jonathan, in particular, was an absolute pleasure to work with. He not only listened to my specific requirements but also guided me through the entire process with patience and expertise. What truly stood out to me was the level of communication and care demonstrated by the team. Jonathan ensured that I was informed at every stage of the design and creation process, making me feel confident and reassured throughout. When I finally received the earrings, they exceeded all of my expectations. The craftsmanship was impeccable, and the quality of the rubies was simply breathtaking. I presented them to my wife on our special day, and the joy and awe in her eyes were priceless. It was a moment I will cherish forever, and I have GemsNY to thank for making it all possible. Not only did GemsNY create the perfect pair of earrings for me, but they also did so at a remarkably competitive price. Their dedication to customer satisfaction is truly commendable, and I will undoubtedly return to them for all my future jewelry needs. If you're searching for a jewelry company that not only delivers exceptional quality but also prioritizes your unique vision and needs, I wholeheartedly recommend GemsNY. Thank you, Jonathan, and the entire team, for your outstanding service and for helping me create a cherished memory that will last a lifetime.
J J Coleman
244 days ago

Ruby earrings for fortieth anniversary

My evaluation for gemsny.com I had a sure design I used to be on the lookout for and GemsNY constructed the earrings for me at a really aggressive worth. Jonathon was nice and stayed in shut communication by means of all the course of. I would undoubtedly purchase there once more.
S Sally
265 days ago

I highly recommend GemsNY.

I cannot express how thrilled I am with my experience at GemsNY. From the moment I set foot on their website, I knew I was in for something special. The customer service I received was unparalleled, and the quality of their products is truly exceptional. When I reached out to Jonathan, I was astounded by his commitment to helping me find the perfect diamond ring within my budget. His expertise and patience were invaluable throughout the entire process. The end result was a stunning piece that surpassed all my expectations. I am overjoyed with my purchase and will undoubtedly be returning to GemsNY for all my future jewelry needs. Thank you, GemsNY, for making this such a memorable and enjoyable experience. I cannot recommend you enough to anyone in search of elegance and excellence.
S Sally
265 days ago

Discover Unparalleled Excellence with GemsNY: A Heartwarming Experience

Let me share my exceptional experience with GemsNY, a gem of an online store that exceeded all my expectations. From the moment I laid my eyes on their website, I knew I was in for a treat. The service I received was nothing short of exceptional, with a level of care and attention that made me feel truly valued as a customer. The quality of the diamond ring I purchased was simply unparalleled. It sparkled with a brilliance that captured the essence of my love story. Working closely with Jonathan was a delight; his expertise and willingness to go the extra mile ensured that I found the perfect ring within my budget. This purchase wasn't just about acquiring a piece of jewelry; it was about crafting a symbol of love and commitment. GemsNY understood this sentiment and helped me translate my vision into reality. I am enamored with my ring and cherish it as a reflection of my journey. Without a doubt, I will be returning to GemsNY for all my future jewelry needs. The trust, transparency, and top-notch service they offer are truly commendable. To anyone in search of a memorable and meaningful jewelry buying experience, I wholeheartedly recommend GemsNY. They are more than just a store; they are curators of precious moments.
L Liz A.
327 days ago

Excellent!

I stumbled upon GemsNY while searching for the perfect emerald ring, and I'm so glad I did. After reading countless positive reviews, I decided to take the leap and order a stunning 2.26 ct. emerald with a gold pave setting from their website. Despite my excitement, I couldn't help but feel a bit apprehensive about making such a significant purchase online. To ease my concerns, I reached out to their customer service team and was fortunate enough to speak with Jonathan. From the moment Jonathan answered the phone, I knew I was in good hands. Patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly helpful, he guided me through the entire process with the utmost care and professionalism. His expertise was evident as he assisted me in selecting the perfect emerald and matching setting, patiently addressing all my questions and concerns along the way. Jonathan's personalized attention made me feel valued as a customer, and his willingness to go above and beyond truly set GemsNY apart. To my delight, the ring arrived promptly and exceeded all my expectations. Its exquisite craftsmanship and undeniable beauty left me speechless. Every detail was meticulously curated, and the emerald's lustrous green hue was simply mesmerizing. The compliments I've received on my ring are endless, and I find myself admiring it at every opportunity. If you're in search of exceptional quality and unparalleled customer service, look no further than GemsNY. My experience with them has been nothing short of extraordinary, and I wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone in the market for exquisite jewelry. Thank you, GemsNY, for making my dream ring a reality.
L Liz A.
327 days ago

Truly Exceptional Experience with GemsNY!

My journey with GemsNY was nothing short of extraordinary. After stumbling upon their stunning collection online, I was immediately drawn to a magnificent 2.26 ct. emerald with a gold pave setting. While hesitant about making such a significant purchase online, I decided to reach out to a representative before proceeding. Enter Jonathan - a gem of a representative! His patience, expertise, and genuine willingness to assist shone through our conversation. Jonathan guided me flawlessly in selecting the ideal emerald and setting, addressing all my queries promptly and effectively. His assurance and professionalism alleviated my initial apprehensions. Upon placing my order, the delivery was surprisingly swift, and the moment I laid eyes on my ring, I was mesmerized. The craftsmanship, quality, and beauty far exceeded my expectations, leaving me speechless. GemsNY truly delivered perfection wrapped in luxury! I wholeheartedly endorse GemsNY to anyone seeking not just superior jewelry but also unparalleled customer service. Thank you, Jonathan, and the entire GemsNY team, for making this experience truly exceptional!
N Nuke Ops
354 days ago

Excellent customer service and quality product

I can't help but gush about my incredible experience with gemsny.com. When I decided to purchase a pair of diamond earrings for my wife's anniversary present, I never imagined the level of service and quality that awaited me. From the moment I placed my order, the team at gemsny.com, particularly Jonathan, went above and beyond to ensure that I received nothing but the best. Jonathan personally reached out to me and graciously informed me that the initial diamonds I had selected did not meet their high standards. Instead of simply fulfilling the order, he took it upon himself to handpick two larger, better-cut, and higher-quality diamonds – all at no additional cost to me. I was genuinely moved by their dedication to excellence. When the earrings arrived, I was simply astonished. The sparkle and brilliance of the diamonds took my breath away, and I knew that I had made the perfect choice for my wife. Seeing the joy on her face when she opened the box was priceless. It's moments like these that make me a loyal customer of gemsny.com. If you're searching for exceptional quality, outstanding customer service, and a team that truly cares about your satisfaction, I wholeheartedly recommend gemsny.com. They've won my trust, and I'm certain they'll exceed your expectations too.
N Nuke Ops
354 days ago

Unmatched Service and Dazzling Quality: A Customer’s Joyful Discovery

I recently had the pleasure of indulging in gemsny.com's splendid offerings, and let me tell you, the experience was nothing short of magical. While browsing for a pair of diamond earrings, I was pleasantly surprised by the proactive approach of Jonathan, who reached out to notify me that the initial diamonds chosen fell short of their stringent standards. Instead of settling, Jonathan seamlessly upgraded the stones to larger, better-cut, superior quality diamonds, all without a hint of additional cost. Upon receiving the revamped earrings, I was truly spellbound. As an anniversary gift for my beloved wife, the earrings exceeded all expectations, radiating unparalleled beauty and brilliance. Witnessing her awe and delight reinforced my trust and loyalty to gemsny, a brand that demonstrates unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction. If you seek a blend of exceptional service and exquisite quality, look no further than gemsny—you'll be in for a treat just like I was!
J Jennifer Brooks
365 days ago

Purchased an emerald in 2022 from…

I cannot say enough positive words about my experience with GemsNY. From the moment I made my first inquiry, the customer service I received was exceptional. I recently purchased a stunning emerald from them and had a platinum setting custom-made for it. The craftsmanship was truly impeccable, and the end result was mesmerizing. However, after a few months of wearing my cherished ring, I encountered an issue. A baguette diamond fell out of the setting, causing me great distress. I reached out to GemsNY, and they swiftly attended to my concerns. Although the warranty only covered the setting, they were incredibly understanding and helped facilitate the repair process. While I had to cover the cost of replacing the diamond, their support and guidance made the entire ordeal much more manageable. Fast forward to today, and I am once again overwhelmed with gratitude for their attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction. When I noticed another diamond becoming loose in its setting, GemsNY took swift action to rectify the situation, sparing me from any further distress. I cannot emphasize enough how thrilled I am with their customer service. GemsNY has not only provided me with a breathtaking piece of jewelry but has also gone above and beyond to ensure that it remains as perfect as the day I received it. I wholeheartedly recommend GemsNY to anyone in search of exquisite gemstones and unparalleled service. Thank you, GemsNY, for your outstanding craftsmanship and unwavering dedication to your customers.
J Jennifer Brooks
365 days ago

A Gem of a Purchase: My Dazzling Emerald Tale with GemsNY

Having taken the plunge in 2022 on GemsNY's website, I embarked on a journey to find the perfect emerald, accompanied by a lustrous platinum setting. Little did I know that this sparkling adventure would soon be marred by a series of unfortunate events. Within a mere two months of donning my prized possession, tragedy struck as a baguette diamond bid farewell to its setting, leaving me in dismay. To compound matters, this mishap was deemed beyond the scope of their warranty, focusing solely on the setting's coverage. Reluctantly, I parted with several hundred dollars for the return journey, bearing the additional burden of replacing the lost diamond to avert the need for a premature insurance claim. As the calendar flipped to April, a new chapter unfolded, with the ominous realization that the remaining diamond teetered on the brink of departure. Thankfully, vigilance averted disaster this time, sparing me from facing a repeat scenario. Despite the allure of the ring's beauty, the subpar setting quality and the brand's apparent apathy towards resolution tainted my overall experience. While GemsNY's allure may dazzle during the initial purchase, the luster dims post-sale interactions. The stark contrast between exceptional customer service pre-purchase and its stark decline thereafter serves as a poignant cautionary tale. In the realm of gem acquisition, let wisdom guide your choices to avoid a fate like mine.
S Scott
404 days ago

Exceptional Service and Fair Pricing at GemsNY – A Retired Jeweler’s Perspective

As a retired jeweler, I have high standards when it comes to gemstones and quality craftsmanship. When sourcing the main diamond for my fiancée's ring and two unique tsavorite garnets, I turned to GemsNY. Their extensive selection and rave reviews drew me in, and I am thrilled to say that their service exceeded my expectations. Not only did GemsNY offer fair pricing, but their willingness to go above and beyond was truly remarkable. When one of the stones fell out, they were able to provide me with a perfect match, a feat that even my trusted jeweler could not accomplish. Their attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction left a lasting impression on me. I highly recommend GemsNY to anyone in search of exquisite gemstones and impeccable service. Trust me, as a retired jeweler, I know quality when I see it, and GemsNY delivers on every front. Thank you, GemsNY, for helping me create a truly special piece of jewelry for my fiancée.
S Scott
404 days ago

Transforming Moments: A Retired Jeweler’s Journey with GemsNY

As a retired jeweler, I have always had a keen eye for exceptional gemstones. When it came time to choose the perfect pieces for my fiancée, I turned to GemsNY, and they exceeded all my expectations. From the breathtaking main diamond to the elusive tsavorite garnets, every stone sparkled with brilliance. Although a mishap occurred and one of the stones fell out, GemsNY came to the rescue with a perfect match, showcasing their dedication to customer satisfaction. Their pricing is not only fair but reflects the true value of their exquisite stones. The impeccable service I received reassured me that I had made the right choice. I initially selected GemsNY based on glowing reviews, and now I wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone seeking top-notch quality and service. Trust GemsNY to transform your special moments into unforgettable memories.
G Greg Johnson
1055 days ago

GEMNY ruby and diamond ring

A Heartfelt Testimonial for GEMNY's Exquisite Ruby and Diamond Ring My GEMNY experience has been nothing short of extraordinary. I recently indulged in a ruby and diamond ring from their extensive collection, and the entire process has been a testament to their exceptional service and craftsmanship. What immediately stood out was the fairness in pricing, a rare find in the world of fine jewelry. The quality and craftsmanship of the ring surpassed my expectations, speaking volumes about GEMNY's commitment to excellence. Despite having to craft the mounting from scratch, the delivery was surprisingly swift. In fact, the ring graced my doorstep more than a week before the promised date, a delightful surprise that further amplified my satisfaction. GEMNY's website is a true gem, boasting user-friendly navigation and a unique feature that allows customers to visualize the placement of stones in their chosen jewelry pieces. This innovative approach provided me with a clear picture of the finished product, ultimately enhancing my shopping experience. As I eagerly anticipate the arrival of my matching ruby earrings, I find myself already planning my next visit to GEMNY. The allure of their stunning collection and the unparalleled service they offer has undoubtedly won me over as a loyal customer. Thank you, GEMNY, for not only adorning me with exquisite jewels but for crafting an experience that is truly second to none.

Introduction:

Gemsny.com is an online jewelry retailer specializing in exquisite, high-quality gemstone jewelry. With a wide selection of gemstones, including diamonds, sapphires, emeralds, and rubies, Gemsny.com offers customers a convenient platform to shop for stunning pieces at competitive prices.

Pros:

  • Extensive selection of gemstones and jewelry designs
  • Competitive pricing, often lower than brick-and-mortar stores
  • Customization options available for a unique and personalized piece
  • Secure website with a user-friendly interface for easy navigation
  • Fast and reliable shipping options with insurance coverage

Cons:

  • Limited information provided about the sources and origin of gemstones
  • Return policy has some limitations and restocking fees may apply
  • Customer reviews and ratings are not prominently displayed on the website
  • No physical stores for customers to view the jewelry in person

User Experience:

Gemsny.com provides a seamless user experience with a well-structured website layout, making it easy to find specific gemstones or browse through various jewelry categories. The search function allows users to filter their results based on preferred gemstone, metal type, or price range, ensuring a convenient shopping experience.

Pricing and Value for Money:

Gemsny.com offers competitive pricing, often offering prices lower than traditional brick-and-mortar stores for similar quality gemstone jewelry. The value for money is further enhanced by the wide range of customization options available, allowing customers to create their dream jewelry at affordable prices.

Customer Service:

Gemsny.com provides excellent customer service through various channels, including phone and email support. Their knowledgeable and friendly staff is always ready to assist customers with any inquiries or concerns. However, there have been a few instances where response times were slightly delayed.

Product Quality and Selection:

The product quality offered by Gemsny.com is exceptional. Each piece is meticulously crafted by skilled artisans, ensuring superior craftsmanship. The selection of gemstones is vast, with options ranging from classic diamonds to rare and exotic gemstones, making it suitable for a wide range of preferences and occasions.

Website Usability:

The Gemsny.com website is designed with user-friendliness in mind. The navigation is intuitive, allowing customers to easily browse through different categories and product pages. The website is also mobile-friendly, ensuring a seamless experience for users on smartphones and tablets.

Returns and Exchanges:

Gemsny.com has a reasonable return policy, allowing customers to return or exchange their purchases within 30 days of delivery. However, it's important to note that restocking fees may apply, and the jewelry must be in its original condition to qualify for a refund or exchange.

Promotions and Discounts:

Gemsny.com regularly offers promotions and discounts, including seasonal sales and special offers on select gemstones or jewelry designs. Customers are advised to sign up for the newsletter or follow the website's social media accounts to stay updated on these exciting deals.

Reputation:

Gemsny.com has built a solid reputation in the online jewelry industry. With years of experience and positive feedback from satisfied customers, the company has gained trust and recognition for their quality craftsmanship and customer service.

Payment Options:

Gemsny.com accepts various payment options, including major credit cards (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover) and PayPal. The secure payment gateway ensures the safety of customers' personal and financial information.

Loyalty Programs:

Currently, Gemsny.com does not have a specific loyalty program in place for its customers. However, they occasionally offer exclusive discounts and perks to repeat customers or those subscribed to their newsletter.

Customer Reviews:

While customer reviews and ratings are available on Gemsny.com, they are not prominently displayed on the product pages. Customers are encouraged to provide feedback, but it may require some navigating to find these reviews.

Community Involvement:

There is limited information available regarding Gemsny.com's community involvement or social responsibility initiatives. The website does not highlight any specific partnerships or contributions to charitable organizations.

Shipping and Costs:

Gemsny.com offers fast and reliable shipping options, including insured shipping to ensure the safety of valuable jewelry during transit. Shipping costs vary depending on the destination and the value of the order. However, the website provides a shipping cost calculator to estimate the charges before finalizing the purchase.

In conclusion, Gemsny.com offers a comprehensive online platform for customers to explore and purchase a wide variety of gemstone jewelry. With competitive pricing, excellent product quality, and user-friendly website navigation, Gemsny.com is a reliable choice for those seeking exceptional gemstone jewelry.