Americanstationery Reviews

Voted Poor (2/5)

70 Votes

70 Reviews

Vote Now

In the Big Sales category

Pie-Chart Analysis

30% users rated Terrible
31% users rated Poor
23% users rated Average
11% users rated Very Good
4% users rated Excellent
Write a review

Introduction is an online stationery store that offers a wide range of personalized paper products, such as note cards, stationery sets, and invitations. With a reputation for quality products and exceptional customer service, American Stationery has been serving customers for over 100 years. In this review, we will explore the various aspects of the website, including its pros and cons, user experience, pricing, customer service, product quality and selection, website usability, returns and exchanges, promotions and discounts, reputation, payment options, loyalty programs, customer reviews, community involvement, shipping, and costs.

Pros and Cons

Pros: - Vast selection of personalized paper products - High-quality materials and printing - Easy-to-use customization process - Fast and reliable shipping - Knowledgeable and helpful customer service Cons: - Prices can be on the higher side compared to similar online stores - Limited selection for non-personalized stationery items

User Experience

The website offers a pleasing and intuitive user experience. The navigation is straightforward, allowing users to easily browse through various categories and products. The customization process is seamless, providing step-by-step instructions and offering a range of options to personalize each item. The website's search function is also efficient, enabling users to find specific products quickly. Overall, the user experience is smooth and hassle-free.

Pricing and Value for Money

American Stationery offers premium personalized paper products, which come with a slightly higher price tag. While the prices may be on the higher side compared to some competitors, the quality of the materials and printing justifies the cost. Additionally, customers can be confident that they are investing in durable and well-crafted stationery products that will leave a lasting impression. However, for customers seeking more budget-friendly options, the website might not be the most affordable choice.


If you are looking for alternative online stationery stores, some popular options include Minted, Paper Source, and Shutterfly. Minted offers a wide range of stylish and modern designs, while Paper Source provides a diverse selection of unique stationery items. Shutterfly specializes in personalized photo products, including stationery. These alternatives may be worth considering if you are looking for specific features or designs that American Stationery does not offer.

Customer Service

American Stationery has a strong reputation for providing excellent customer service. Their knowledgeable and friendly representatives are readily available to assist with any queries or concerns. Customers can reach out through phone, email, or live chat, and can expect prompt and helpful responses. The website also provides a comprehensive FAQ section, addressing common questions and concerns.

Product Quality and Selection

American Stationery excels in both product quality and selection. Their personalized paper products are crafted with care, using high-quality materials that ensure a premium finish. The selection includes a wide range of designs, styles, and themes, catering to diverse preferences and occasions. Whether you're looking for elegant wedding invitations or cheerful holiday cards, American Stationery offers a variety of options to suit your needs.

Website Usability

The American Stationery website is designed to be user-friendly and easy to navigate. The layout is clean and organized, with intuitive menus and clear categorization. The customization process is straightforward, allowing users to preview their personalized designs before making a purchase. Additionally, the website loads quickly and is responsive across different devices, ensuring a seamless browsing experience.

Returns and Exchanges

American Stationery has a fair return and exchange policy. If customers receive a defective or incorrect product, they can contact customer service within 30 days of receipt to initiate a return or exchange. However, personalized items cannot be returned or exchanged unless there is a manufacturing defect or error. It is advisable to carefully review the customization details before placing an order to avoid any disappointment.

Promotions and Discounts

American Stationery occasionally offers promotions and discounts, which are typically advertised on their website or sent via email newsletters. Customers can take advantage of these offers to save on their purchases. Additionally, the website has a clearance section where discounted items can be found. Joining their mailing list is a great way to stay updated with upcoming promotions and discounts.


American Stationery has built a solid reputation over the past century, providing customers with high-quality personalized paper products. Their attention to detail, commitment to customer satisfaction, and long-standing presence in the industry have contributed to their positive reputation. Many satisfied customers have praised the exceptional quality and design of their stationery items.

Payment Options

American Stationery offers a variety of payment options to suit customer preferences. These include major credit cards such as Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. Customers can also choose to pay via PayPal for added convenience and security. The website ensures that all transactions are secure and encrypted, safeguarding customers' personal and financial information.

Loyalty Programs

American Stationery does not currently offer a loyalty program. However, customers can create an account on the website to enjoy a faster checkout process and track their order history. Creating an account also allows customers to receive exclusive offers, updates, and recommendations based on their previous purchases.

Customer Reviews

Customer reviews for American Stationery are overwhelmingly positive. Satisfied customers appreciate the quality of the products, the ease of customization, and the attentive customer service. Many reviewers highlight that the personalized stationery items from American Stationery make for memorable gifts and are highly appreciated by recipients. The positive reviews reflect the company's dedication to providing top-notch products and services.

Community Involvement

American Stationery actively participates in community engagement and philanthropic endeavors. They support various charitable organizations and community initiatives, demonstrating their commitment to making a positive impact. By contributing to causes that are important to their customers, American Stationery fosters a sense of community and social responsibility.

Shipping and Costs

American Stationery offers reliable shipping services within the United States and select international destinations. The shipping costs and delivery times vary based on the chosen shipping method and order details. Customers can select from standard, rush, or overnight shipping options to meet their specific requirements. The website provides transparent information regarding shipping costs and estimated delivery times during the checkout process. In conclusion, is a reputable online destination for personalized paper products. While the prices may be higher compared to some competitors, the quality, customization options, and exceptional customer service make it a worthwhile investment for those seeking premium stationery items. With a vast selection of designs and styles, user-friendly website interface, reliable shipping, and positive customer reviews, American Stationery stands out as a trusted choice for all your personalized stationery needs.