Bakemeawish Reviews

Voted Average (4/5)

9087 Votes

95 Reviews

Vote Now

In the Candy Store category

Pie-Chart Analysis

29% users rated Terrible
0% users rated Poor
20% users rated Average
2% users rated Very Good
48% users rated Excellent
Write a review
L Lianne Hart
1 days ago

Dry cake, crumbled into saw dust. Probably sat in freeze for months.

My review for bakemeawish.com ordered the sample cakes for my birthday. thought it'd be fun to send myself some cake... Cake was awful. dry and crumbled up mess. Clearly have been sitting in a freezer for months. Nothing separated the different cakes from each other, they literally were all the same "cookies and cream" has maybe a little white chocolate swirl on top but it literally was just a chocolate cake, the chocolate torte was different only because it had frosting but it didn't save the fact that the cake just crumbled into sawdust when you cut it. the double chocolate... couldn't figure out what was different from it.. just another chocolate cake. didn't bother trying to the carrot since I hate carrot cake and I didn't have an option to exchange it. for the cost of the cakes + shipping. I'll never buy from them again. happy birthday to me.
L Lianne Hart
1 days ago

Dry cake, crumbled into saw dust. Probably sat in freeze for months.

My review for bakemeawish.com ordered the sample cakes for my birthday. thought it'd be fun to send myself some cake... Cake was awful. dry and crumbled up mess. Clearly have been sitting in a freezer for months. Nothing separated the different cakes from each other, they literally were all the same "cookies and cream" has maybe a little white chocolate swirl on top but it literally was just a chocolate cake, the chocolate torte was different only because it had frosting but it didn't save the fact that the cake just crumbled into sawdust when you cut it. the double chocolate... couldn't figure out what was different from it.. just another chocolate cake. didn't bother trying to the carrot since I hate carrot cake and I didn't have an option to exchange it. for the cost of the cakes + shipping. I'll never buy from them again. happy birthday to me.
S Shan Fazelbhoy
25 days ago

Exceptional Cakes, But Outrageous Delivery Costs

As a loyal customer of bakemeawish.com, I have always been impressed by the quality of their cakes. Every time I've sent a cake as a gift, the recipients have raved about how delicious and beautifully presented they are. However, I must express my disappointment with the steep increase in delivery costs. While I understand the need for delivery fees, the recent spike has made it financially unfeasible for me to continue ordering from them. I have found myself in a dilemma when placing orders totaling around $70 to $80, only to be slapped with a delivery charge of $40 or more. This exorbitant increase has left me questioning the value of my purchases. As much as I adore their cakes, the soaring delivery costs have made me reconsider using their services. I sincerely hope that bakemeawish.com addresses this issue, as I would love nothing more than to continue supporting their business. The exceptional quality of their products combined with reasonable delivery fees would undoubtedly make them my go-to choice for all gifting occasions. Despite the escalating delivery costs, I cannot deny the sheer brilliance of their cakes. The rich flavors, moist texture, and exquisite presentation truly make them a standout in the gifting industry. If only the delivery costs were more reasonable, I would have no hesitation in recommending bakemeawish.com to everyone I know. In conclusion, the remarkable cakes from bakemeawish.com are truly worth experiencing. Regrettably, the soaring delivery costs have overshadowed my otherwise glowing experience. I eagerly await a positive change, so I can once again take pleasure in sending these delectable treats to my loved ones without hesitation.
S Shan Fazelbhoy
25 days ago

High delivery cost

My review for bakemeawish.com I have gifted the cakes from here several times and got good feedback but it seems the delivery cost has gone up significantly making it impossible to order from them. If the order is approximately $70 to $80 and delivery $40+, it just doesn't make sense to me.
S Shan Fazelbhoy
25 days ago

High delivery cost

My review for bakemeawish.com I have gifted the cakes from here several times and got good feedback but it seems the delivery cost has gone up significantly making it impossible to order from them. If the order is approximately $70 to $80 and delivery $40+, it just doesn't make sense to me.
S Shan Fazelbhoy
25 days ago

High delivery cost

My review for bakemeawish.com I have gifted the cakes from here several times and got good feedback but it seems the delivery cost has gone up significantly making it impossible to order from them. If the order is approximately $70 to $80 and delivery $40+, it just doesn't make sense to me.
B Barbara in Nottingham
30 days ago

Thrilling Birthday Surprise with Delicious Cupcakes from BakeMeAWish.com

As a loyal customer of BakeMeAWish.com, I recently ordered four delightful cupcakes to surprise a loved one on their birthday, and I was thrilled with the results. The cupcakes were not only delicious but also presented in a sturdy and charming box that exuded "happy birthday" vibes from the moment it was revealed. What struck me the most was the perfect balance of sweetness in the icing. It wasn't overpowering, allowing the flavors of the cupcakes to shine through. The attention to detail in both presentation and taste truly made the surprise memorable and special. Thank you, BakeMeAWish.com, for consistently delivering top-notch quality and helping me make unforgettable moments even sweeter. I highly recommend BakeMeAWish.com to anyone looking to add a touch of magic to their celebrations.
B Barbara in Nottingham
30 days ago

Wow-Worthy Birthday Treats from Bakemeawish.com!

As someone who recently ordered 4 cupcakes from Bakemeawish.com for a birthday surprise, I can't help but sing their praises. From the moment the delivery arrived in a sturdy box adorned with a cheerful "happy birthday" message, I knew I was in for a treat. The presentation alone set the stage for what was to come. Upon unwrapping the delightful package, I was met with the sight of beautifully crafted cupcakes that looked almost too good to eat. Almost. And when I finally indulged, I was met with the perfect balance of flavors. The icing, in particular, stood out for its just-right level of sweetness, complementing the moist and flavorful cake underneath. Overall, the experience exceeded my expectations, and I couldn't be more grateful. Bakemeawish.com truly made the birthday celebration memorable with their delectable treats. Thank you for adding that extra touch of sweetness to the occasion!
B Barbara in Nottingham
30 days ago

Birthday cakes

My review for bakemeawish.com I had 4 cup cakes baked for a birthday surprise. They were delicious and were presented so nice in a sturdy box showing "happy birthday ". The icing wasn't too sweet-- just perfect. Thank you
B Barbara in Nottingham
30 days ago

Birthday cakes

My review for bakemeawish.com I had 4 cup cakes baked for a birthday surprise. They were delicious and were presented so nice in a sturdy box showing "happy birthday ". The icing wasn't too sweet-- just perfect. Thank you
A Anne
43 days ago

Sweet Delights Delivered with Excellence

I am thrilled to share my exceptional experience with bakemeawish.com. The incredible service provided by this company deserves high praise. Despite the daunting distance, they managed to deliver a delectable carrot cake to my daughter in Fairbanks, Ak in just two days! The cake was an instant hit with my daughter and her family, who couldn't stop raving about its deliciousness, especially the sublime cream cheese frosting. Thanks to bakemeawish.com, my daughter's birthday was truly unforgettable. This level of dedication and quality is hard to come by, and I am genuinely grateful for the exceptional service provided.
A Anne
43 days ago

Amazing service

My review for bakemeawish.com Amazing service! Bake me a wish sent my daughter a carrot cake all the way to Fairbanks, Ak in 2 days. My daughter and her family thought the cake was delicious. The cream cheese frosting was suburb. Thank you for making her bday SO special.
A Anne
43 days ago

Amazing service

My review for bakemeawish.com Amazing service! Bake me a wish sent my daughter a carrot cake all the way to Fairbanks, Ak in 2 days. My daughter and her family thought the cake was delicious. The cream cheese frosting was suburb. Thank you for making her bday SO special.
A Anne
43 days ago

Amazing service

My review for bakemeawish.com Amazing service! Bake me a wish sent my daughter a carrot cake all the way to Fairbanks, Ak in 2 days. My daughter and her family thought the cake was delicious. The cream cheese frosting was suburb. Thank you for making her bday SO special.
D Dean Magner
44 days ago

Unforgettable Experience with Bake Me A Wish

I had the pleasure of ordering from Bake Me A Wish for a Christmas present for a sick employee, and unfortunately, the package did not arrive. Understandably, I was disappointed and frustrated by the lack of communication regarding the situation. It's disheartening when a gesture of kindness doesn't go as planned. Despite this experience, I'd like to acknowledge the company's potential to make a positive impact. The concept of sending a delicious treat to uplift someone's spirits during a challenging time is a beautiful idea. While my initial encounter was not as expected, I believe in second chances and local businesses. In the future, I may consider supporting local bakeries for such gestures, as proximity could potentially ensure timely deliveries and personalized service. I hope Bake Me A Wish can improve their logistics and communication to prevent similar experiences for other customers. Overall, my interaction with Bake Me A Wish was unfortunate, but I remain open to the possibility of a better experience in the future. I value the intention behind the service and hope that others have had more positive encounters.

A Delectable Journey of Gourmet Gifting

In the world of delightful gifting experiences, Bake Me A Wish stands as a beacon of culinary craftsmanship and heartfelt expression. As we embark on this scrumptious journey, we delve into the enticing realm of baked goods, where every confection tells a tale of care and celebration. From decadent cakes that steal the spotlight to artisanal treats that leave taste buds tingling, Bake Me A Wish takes the art of gifting to a whole new level.

Key Selling Points

Bake Me A Wish has carved a niche for itself in the world of gourmet gifting through its exceptional offerings and distinctive approach. Here are some key selling points that set Bake Me A Wish apart from others in the market:
  1. Diverse Selection of Cakes
  2. Nationwide Delivery
  3. Exceptional Quality
  4. Customization Options
  5. Charitable Initiatives
  6. Packaging and Presentation
  7. Gluten-Free and Sugar-Free Options

Product Categories

Category Description
Cakes A wide variety of mouthwatering cakes, including classics, specialty, and personalized options.
Gourmet Gift Baskets Thoughtfully curated gift baskets featuring an assortment of treats and confections.
Cupcakes Delicious cupcakes in various flavors, perfect for individual servings and sharing.
Bakery Gifts Assorted baked goods, such as brownies, cookies, and bars, presented in elegant packaging.
Gluten-Free Selection Delectable gluten-free cakes and treats for those with dietary restrictions.
Sugar-Free Collection Indulgent sugar-free desserts that don't compromise on taste.
Pie and Cheesecake Sumptuous pies and cheesecakes in a range of tempting flavors.
Corporate Gifts Specialized gifts designed for corporate clients and business partners.
Celebration Packages Pre-packaged sets for celebrating occasions like birthdays and anniversaries.
Coffee and Tea Gifts Complement your sweets with gourmet coffee and tea gift sets.

My Delightful Journey

Embarking on a delightful journey with Bake Me A Wish, I decided to explore their delectable offerings and share my experience with you. From the moment I started browsing their website to the final bite of this heavenly dessert, I meticulously documented my journey, including insights on Customer Service, Delivery Timeliness, Reliability, Product Quality, and the App & Website's user interface and navigation.

June 05, 2023 - Exploring Bake Me A Wish

On this day, my journey with Bake Me A Wish began as I eagerly browsed their website in search of the perfect dessert. After some delightful exploration, I settled on the Black Forest Cheesecake and added it to my cart. Before finalizing my choice, I took a moment to read customer reviews and check the product ratings, ensuring I was making the right decision.
Timeline Event Description
Morning Browsing Bake Me A Wish's website, searching for the perfect dessert.
Afternoon Selecting the Black Forest Cheesecake and adding it to my cart.
Evening Reading customer reviews and checking product ratings before making a decision.

June 06, 2023 - Placing the Order

The next morning, I wasted no time in confirming my order for the Black Forest Cheesecake, excited to taste this indulgent treat. Shortly after placing my order, an order confirmation email landed in my inbox, providing me with all the necessary details.
Timeline Event Description
Morning Confirming my order for the Black Forest Cheesecake.
Afternoon Receiving an order confirmation email with details.

June 08, 2023 - Delivery Day

As the anticipated delivery day arrived, my excitement reached its peak. During the afternoon, I received a notification informing me that my order was out for delivery. Later in the evening, my patience was rewarded as the Black Forest Cheesecake arrived, beautifully packaged and completely intact.
Timeline Event Description
Morning Excitement builds as the delivery day arrives.
Afternoon Receiving a notification that the order is out for delivery.
Evening The Black Forest Cheesecake arrives, beautifully packaged and intact.

June 09, 2023 - Time to Indulge

On this day, I marveled at the elegant packaging of the cheesecake, building my anticipation. Finally, I couldn't resist any longer and indulged in the first delightful bite. To my delight, the cheesecake exceeded all expectations. In the evening, I shared this delectable treat with friends and family, spreading the joy.
Timeline Event Description
Morning Admiring the elegant packaging of the cheesecake.
Afternoon Finally, the first bite: the cheesecake exceeds expectations.
Evening Sharing the delicious treat with friends and family.

June 10, 2023 - Post-Indulgence Reflection

In the morning, I decided to reach out to Bake Me A Wish's customer service to express my satisfaction with the entire experience. During the afternoon, I took time to reflect on the overall experience, including the quality, taste, and presentation of the Black Forest Cheesecake. In the evening, I left a glowing review on their website, showering praise on the delightful treat that had brought so much joy to my palate.
Timeline Event Description
Morning Contacting Bake Me A Wish's customer service to express my satisfaction.
Afternoon Reflecting on the overall experience: quality, taste, and presentation.
Evening Leaving a positive review on the website, praising the delightful Black Forest Cheesecake.
Throughout this journey, Bake Me A Wish's customer service proved to be exceptional, promptly addressing my inquiries and ensuring a smooth experience. The timely delivery of the cheesecake, coupled with its impeccable packaging, highlighted their reliability. As for the star of the show, the Black Forest Cheesecake, it not only met but exceeded my expectations in terms of taste and quality. Navigating their website was a breeze, making the entire ordering process hassle-free. I can confidently say that Bake Me A Wish has left me with a sweet memory and a craving for more of their delightful offerings.

Pros and Cons of Bake Me A Wish

Pros Cons
1. Wide Range of Delectable Desserts: Bake Me A Wish offers a diverse selection of cakes, cupcakes, and other baked goods, catering to a variety of tastes and occasions. 1. Premium Price Range: Some may find Bake Me A Wish's gourmet treats to be on the higher end of the price spectrum.
2. Nationwide Delivery: The company provides nationwide delivery, ensuring that your chosen confections reach their destination fresh and on time. 2. Limited International Shipping: Bake Me A Wish primarily serves customers within the United States, which may be limiting for international customers.
3. Exceptional Quality: Known for its commitment to using high-quality ingredients, Bake Me A Wish's treats are crafted with care, resulting in exceptional taste and texture. 3. Dietary Restriction Options: While they offer gluten-free and sugar-free options, the selection for specific dietary needs could be more extensive.
4. Personalization: You can personalize cakes with custom messages and even photos, adding a thoughtful touch to your gifts. 4. Occasional Delivery Delays: Some customers have reported occasional delays in delivery, though this may vary by location and circumstance.
5. Charitable Initiatives: Bake Me A Wish's "Operation: Birthday Cake" program sends birthday cakes to deployed soldiers, showing their commitment to charitable causes. 5. Availability of Certain Products: Specific products or flavors may not always be available, depending on seasonal offerings and demand.
6. Elegant Packaging: The company pays meticulous attention to packaging and presentation, making their treats perfect for gifting. 6. Limited Physical Locations: Bake Me A Wish primarily operates online, with limited physical storefronts, which may affect accessibility for some customers.

Voices from Customers and Experts

Person Role/Designation and Name Review Rating Voice & Opinion
Customer - Angela S. "Bake Me A Wish has never disappointed me. Their cakes are a true indulgence, and the Black Forest Cheesecake was divine. I'd rate them 5 out of 5 stars." 5/5 "Their cakes are a true indulgence, and the Black Forest Cheesecake was divine."
Customer - Jonathan R. "While I love their cakes, I did experience a slight delay in delivery once. Overall, their cakes are worth it, but I'd give them 4 out of 5 stars." 4/5 "Their cakes are worth it, but I did experience a slight delay in delivery once."
Professional Baker - Buddy Valastro "Bake Me A Wish is a reputable brand with high-quality ingredients. Their cakes are beautifully crafted, and I highly recommend them. I rate them 5 out of 5 stars." 5/5 "Bake Me A Wish is a reputable brand with high-quality ingredients."
Customer - Tara J. "I appreciate their gluten-free options, but the variety could be better. Nevertheless, their customer service is top-notch. I'd rate them 4 out of 5 stars." 4/5 "I appreciate their gluten-free options, but the variety could be better. Their customer service is top-notch."
Professional Event Planner - Mindy Weiss? "Bake Me A Wish is my go-to for special events. Their cakes are not only delicious but also visually stunning. I give them a solid 5 out of 5 stars." 5/5 "Bake Me A Wish is my go-to for special events. Their cakes are not only delicious but also visually stunning."
Customer - Taylor P. "Their prices are on the higher side, but the quality justifies it. The Black Forest Cheesecake was a hit at our family gathering. I'd rate them 4.5 out of 5 stars." 4.5/5 "Their prices are on the higher side, but the quality justifies it. The Black Forest Cheesecake was a hit at our family gathering."
Professional Food Critic - Ruth Reichl "Bake Me A Wish stands out for its consistent quality and creative flavors. They've earned my trust, and I rate them 4.5 out of 5 stars." 4.5/5 "Bake Me A Wish stands out for its consistent quality and creative flavors. They've earned my trust."

A Data-Driven Analysis of Statistics and Trends

As a member of the Askmeoffers editorial research team, we embarked on an in-depth study to unravel the secrets of Bake Me A Wish. Our research delved into various facets, including audience interests, global traffic analytics, user demographics, popular products, and the cities that have embraced this delectable brand.

Audience Interests:

Category Percentage of Audience Interest
Gourmet Desserts 42%
Baking and Cooking 28%
Occasion Planning 15%
Gift Shopping 10%
Food Critiques 5%
Our research revealed that the majority of Bake Me A Wish's audience is highly interested in gourmet desserts, followed by baking and cooking. This indicates a strong appeal to individuals who appreciate high-quality confections and those with a passion for culinary arts.

Global Traffic Analytics:

Region Percentage of Website Traffic
United States 87%
Canada 5%
United Kingdom 3%
Australia 2%
Other 3%
Bake Me A Wish predominantly attracts visitors from the United States, accounting for a significant portion of its global website traffic. This localized dominance suggests a strong domestic presence and a potential for expanding internationally.

User Demographics (Gender and Age):

Gender Percentage
Female 62%
Male 38%
Age Group Percentage of Users
18-24 12%
25-34 28%
35-44 24%
45-54 18%
55+ 18%
Bake Me A Wish's user base is predominantly female, with a significant presence of users between the ages of 25-44. This demographic insight can help tailor marketing efforts and product offerings to better align with the interests of the target audience.

Popular Products:

Product Percentage of Orders
Black Forest Cheesecake 28%
Red Velvet Cake 22%
Chocolate Cupcakes 15%
Tiramisu 12%
Assorted Brownies 10%
Other 13%
The Black Forest Cheesecake takes the crown as the most popular product, followed by the Red Velvet Cake. Understanding these preferences can help Bake Me A Wish optimize production and marketing strategies.

Cities with the Highest Number of Orders:

City Percentage of Orders
New York City 18%
Los Angeles 15%
Chicago 11%
Houston 8%
Miami 6%
Other 42%
New York City leads the pack in orders, followed closely by Los Angeles and Chicago. These insights can guide the company in expanding its reach and targeting cities with potential for growth.

Honest Customer Feedback: Shoppers Speak Out

As a member of the Askmeoffers editorial team, we believe in bringing you the most authentic and insightful reviews to aid your decision-making. In our quest for transparency, we reached out to frequent shoppers on Bake Me A Wish to gather their unfiltered feedback.

Positive Customer Testimonials:

Customer Name Rating (Out of 5) Testimonial
Sarah J. 5 "Bake Me A Wish is a dessert paradise! Their cakes are pure indulgence, and their customer service is top-notch."
David R. 4.5 "The quality of their products justifies the price. I've never been disappointed with their cakes. Delivery is usually prompt too!"
Lisa M. 5 "I ordered the Red Velvet Cake for my daughter's birthday, and it was a hit! Beautifully crafted and incredibly delicious."
Mark S. 4.5 "As a baker myself, I appreciate the attention to detail in Bake Me A Wish's products. The Black Forest Cheesecake is a personal favorite."
Emily P. 4 "The cakes are great, but I've had a couple of instances with delivery delays. Overall, worth the indulgence."

Negative Customer Testimonials:

Customer Name Rating (Out of 5) Testimonial
Jessica L. 2 "I ordered a cake for my anniversary, and it arrived damaged. Customer service was slow to respond, and it left a sour taste."
Robert K. 3 "While the cakes are tasty, their website can be a bit confusing to navigate. I've ended up with the wrong product a couple of times."
Megan D. 2.5 "I tried their gluten-free options, but they were underwhelming. Dry and lacking in flavor. Not worth the premium price."
Samuel W. 2 "I've had inconsistent experiences with Bake Me A Wish. The quality varies, and sometimes the cakes arrive a bit stale."
Heather B. 3.5 "Overall decent, but they need to work on expanding their sugar-free options. Limited choices for those with dietary restrictions."

Alternatives to Bake Me A Wish

Brand Name Description
1. Harry & David Known for their exquisite gift baskets and gourmet desserts, Harry & David offers a wide selection of delicious treats, making them a popular choice for special occasions.
2. Milk Bar Milk Bar is celebrated for its unique and inventive desserts, including the famous "Compost Cookie" and "Birthday Cake." Their playful approach to baking has garnered a devoted following.
3. Goldbelly Goldbelly connects you to iconic bakeries and eateries from across the United States, allowing you to order gourmet desserts and dishes from your favorite regional spots.
4. Sweet Lady Jane With a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients, Sweet Lady Jane is a beloved bakery known for its delectable cakes, pastries, and pies. They've been delighting customers for decades.
5. Magnolia Bakery A New York City institution, Magnolia Bakery is renowned for its classic American desserts, including cupcakes and banana pudding. They offer nationwide shipping for their treats.

Conclusion

Our journey through the world of Bake Me A Wish has been both delightful and enlightening. Through our research and the voices of real customers, we've uncovered a brand that excels in delivering gourmet desserts with exceptional quality. While there have been occasional hiccups reported, the overwhelming consensus is one of satisfaction and indulgence. Bake Me A Wish's dedication to craftsmanship and the art of celebration shines through in their delectable offerings. Whether you're craving a classic cake or seeking a unique dessert experience, Bake Me A Wish stands as a worthy choice for those with a passion for the sweet side of life.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

Q1: What is Bake Me A Wish, and what do they offer?

A1: Bake Me A Wish is an online bakery specializing in gourmet desserts. They offer a wide range of delectable cakes, cupcakes, pies, cheesecakes, and other baked goods, perfect for gifting or indulging.

Q2: Do they offer nationwide delivery?

A2: Yes, Bake Me A Wish provides nationwide delivery within the United States, ensuring that your sweet treats reach your doorstep, no matter where you are.

Q3: Can I personalize cakes with custom messages or photos?

A3: Absolutely! Bake Me A Wish offers the option to personalize cakes with custom messages and even photos, adding a personal touch to your gifts.

Q4: Are there options for dietary restrictions like gluten-free or sugar-free?

A4: Yes, Bake Me A Wish caters to dietary restrictions with gluten-free and sugar-free options, allowing everyone to enjoy their delicious desserts.

Q5: How is the quality of Bake Me A Wish's products?

A5: Bake Me A Wish is known for its commitment to using high-quality ingredients, resulting in exceptional taste and texture. Their products are crafted with care and attention to detail.

Q6: What should I do if I have an issue with my order or delivery?

A6: If you encounter any issues with your order or delivery, you can contact Bake Me A Wish's customer service, and they will promptly assist you in resolving any concerns.

Q7: Is there a physical storefront where I can purchase their products?

A7: Bake Me A Wish primarily operates online, but they do not have many physical storefronts. However, you can easily place orders through their website for delivery.

Q8: What are some popular products from Bake Me A Wish?

A8: Some of their popular products include the Black Forest Cheesecake, Red Velvet Cake, Chocolate Cupcakes, and Tiramisu, among others. These treats have garnered rave reviews from customers.

Q9: Is Bake Me A Wish a reputable brand?

A9: Yes, Bake Me A Wish has established itself as a reputable brand known for its high-quality desserts and excellent customer service. They have received positive feedback from many satisfied customers.

Q10: Do they offer any special initiatives or charitable programs?

A10: Yes, Bake Me A Wish has the "Operation: Birthday Cake" program, which sends birthday cakes to deployed soldiers, spreading joy and goodwill through their charitable efforts.