Feltmansofconeyisland Reviews

Voted Average (3/5)

81 Votes

81 Reviews

Vote Now

In the Big Sales category

Pie-Chart Analysis

15% users rated Terrible
22% users rated Poor
12% users rated Average
27% users rated Very Good
23% users rated Excellent
Write a review


Feltmans of Coney Island is a renowned online store that offers a wide range of high-quality and delicious food products. With a rich history dating back to 1867, Feltmans has been an iconic name in the food industry, especially known for its famous hot dogs. With their online platform, they bring the taste of Coney Island directly to your doorstep.

Pros and Cons


  • A vast selection of mouth-watering food products
  • The use of high-quality ingredients
  • Convenient online shopping experience
  • Wide variety of hot dogs and toppings


  • Shipping costs can be relatively high
  • Limited availability of certain products

User Experience

Feltmans of Coney Island provides users with an intuitive and easy-to-navigate website. The search and filtering options efficiently help users find their desired products. The overall user experience is smooth and hassle-free, making the online shopping process enjoyable.

Pricing and Value for Money

While Feltmans' products might come at a slightly higher price compared to mass-produced alternatives, the quality and taste justify the cost. The use of premium ingredients and dedication to authentic flavors make the products worth the investment. Additionally, the value for money is enhanced by the convenience of having these delectable treats delivered straight to your door.


Although Feltmans of Coney Island stands out for its rich tradition and superior quality, there are a few alternatives worth considering. Nathan's Famous and Brooklyn Hot Dog Company offer similar hot dog experiences, but they might not possess the same historical significance or the extensive selection offered by Feltmans.

Customer Service

Feltmans of Coney Island prioritizes customer satisfaction, evidenced by their exceptional customer service. Their support team is responsive, knowledgeable, and dedicated to resolving any inquiries or concerns promptly. Their commitment to customer satisfaction enhances the overall shopping experience.

Product Quality and Selection

The products at Feltmans of Coney Island are crafted with the utmost care and attention to detail. The hot dogs, in particular, are made from high-quality ingredients, ensuring a delicious and authentic taste. Additionally, their selection goes beyond hot dogs and includes other food items and condiments, providing customers with a diverse range of choices.

Website Usability

The Feltmans of Coney Island website showcases a sleek and modern design that is both visually appealing and user-friendly. The layout promotes easy navigation, allowing customers to quickly find and select their desired items. The website is optimized for various devices, ensuring a seamless experience across desktop and mobile platforms.

Returns and Exchanges

Feltmans of Coney Island offers a hassle-free returns and exchanges policy. If customers are dissatisfied with their purchase or encounter any issues, they can easily initiate a return or exchange process through the website. This customer-centric approach further highlights their commitment to providing a satisfactory shopping experience.

Promotions and Discounts

Feltmans of Coney Island occasionally offers promotions and discounts, allowing customers to enjoy their delectable products at more affordable prices. These promotions are often advertised on their website and social media channels, so keeping an eye out for these deals can result in significant savings.


Feltmans of Coney Island has built a strong reputation over the years, becoming synonymous with quality and authenticity. Their long-standing history in the food industry and their affiliation with the iconic Coney Island brand instill trust and confidence in their customers. Countless positive reviews and testimonials further validate their excellent reputation.

Payment Options

To provide customers with flexibility, Feltmans of Coney Island offers various payment options. Customers can conveniently pay for their purchases using major credit cards, including Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. The secure payment gateway ensures the safety of customers' financial information.

Loyalty Programs

Currently, Feltmans of Coney Island does not offer a formal loyalty program. However, they occasionally reward loyal customers with exclusive discounts and special offers. Keeping an eye on their website and subscribing to their newsletter can help customers stay updated on any loyalty-related perks.

Customer Reviews

Customers rave about Feltmans of Coney Island's products, praising the authentic flavors and outstanding quality. The hot dogs, in particular, receive high acclaim, with many customers considering them the best they have ever tasted. The positive customer reviews further solidify Feltmans' reputation as a trusted and beloved brand.

Community Involvement

Feltmans of Coney Island actively participates in community events and initiatives. They sponsor local events, donate to charities, and support various causes. Their commitment to giving back to the community showcases their dedication to not only providing exceptional food but also being a responsible corporate citizen.

Shipping and Costs

Feltmans of Coney Island offers shipping across the United States. The shipping costs may vary depending on the location and weight of the order. While the shipping costs can be relatively high, they are justified by the secure packaging and reliable delivery service provided by the company. Expedited shipping options are also available for customers who require faster delivery.