Kay Reviews

Voted Good (4/5)

33 Votes

47 Reviews

Vote Now

In the Jewelry Store category

Pie-Chart Analysis

79% users rated Terrible
2% users rated Poor
0% users rated Average
0% users rated Very Good
19% users rated Excellent
Write a review
L Lian Murray
44 days ago

Unforgettable Moments at Kay Jewelry Store, Pembroke Lake Mall

Stepping into Kay Jewellers at Pembroke Lakes Mall, Florida, was like entering a realm of elegance and charm. It was a Friday, and the date was etched in our memories - the 16th of February, a day that marked the beginning of a remarkable journey. Jessie and Keisha, the store's invaluable gems, guided us with such genuine care and attention as we embarked on the quest for our dream wedding bands. Their expertise and warmth made the entire experience unforgettable. The gleam of the jewelry matched the sparkle in our eyes as we discovered the perfect pieces to symbolize our love and commitment. The prices were not just reasonable; they epitomized spectacular value, especially with the incredible deals and offers that adorned the store. Every penny spent felt like an investment in our future together. Our gratitude knows no bounds for the exceptional service we received that day. It was more than just shopping for jewelry; it was about creating memories that will last a lifetime. Kay Jewellers at Pembroke Lakes Mall isn't just a store; it's a haven where dreams come true. Thank you, Jessie and Keisha, for being a part of our special journey.
M Mary McConnell
47 days ago

Heartfelt Redemption: Finding True Value Beyond Discounts

As a hopeful bride-to-be, I ventured into Kay Jewelers, mesmerized by the promise of Black Friday savings. However, my experience left me disheartened and skeptical. The "day before Black Friday" deal felt more like a marketing ploy than a genuine discount. The ring I coveted was supposedly on sale, with urgency instilled in me to make a quick decision. I hesitated, contemplating whether the offer was too good to miss or simply too good to be true. As fate would have it, the sale extended far beyond its purported deadline, revealing the facade of a perpetual discount. Disillusioned, I watched as time passed, the ring remained out of stock, and the promised email notification never reached me. Despite the initial disappointment and feelings of being misled, my journey with Kay Jewelers took a surprising turn. Determined to find true value and authenticity, I sought alternatives and stumbled upon a remarkable discovery. In a twist of fate, I found the exact ring I longed for, not at Kay's, but elsewhere, at a price significantly lower than their inflated "sale" offer. This experience, though tainted by initial frustrations, led me to a profound realization. Beyond the allure of discounts and promotions lies the essence of authenticity and integrity in every purchase. While Kay Jewelers may have missed the mark in delivering on their promises, the invaluable lesson learned resonates deeply. In the pursuit of special moments and cherished keepsakes, the true value transcends mere price tags. It is in the journey of seeking and discovering, where we find genuine treasures that hold meaning beyond monetary savings. My journey with Kay Jewelers may have begun with skepticism and disappointment, but it culminated in a heartfelt redemption. Through this process, I found not only a ring that sparkles with beauty but also a renewed appreciation for authenticity and the unwavering value of genuine experiences. In the end, the greatest treasures are not found in discounts or sales gimmicks but in the authenticity of each cherished moment.
J Jeannie Rettura
50 days ago

Sparkling Memories, Exceptional Service: A Review of kay.com

As the maid of honor for my best friend's wedding, finding the perfect engagement ring and wedding bands was a mission close to my heart. Our journey led us to Kay Jewelers at the Caesar's Bay Shopping Plaza in Brooklyn, and what initially felt like a daunting task quickly transformed into a delightful experience that we will cherish forever. From the moment we stepped into the store, we were greeted by the warm smiles and expert guidance of Jasmin and her dedicated team, including Kayaan and Kierra. Their professionalism and knowledge were unmatched, making us feel like valued guests. The array of ring options at Kay Jewelers was not only extensive but also offered great value, catering to various styles and budgets. What truly set our experience apart was the personalized attention and care we received. Jasmin, Kayaan, and Kierra invested time and effort in understanding our needs, ensuring the rings fit perfectly and reflected the couple's unique style. Their dedication to every detail made the entire process seamless and enjoyable, putting the soon-to-be bride and groom at ease. As we left the store with the rings of their dreams in hand, the joy and excitement on the couple's faces were priceless. Thanks to the exceptional service and professionalism of the team at Kay Jewelers, we not only found the perfect rings but also created unforgettable memories that will shine brightly for years to come.
B Benjamin Theurer
54 days ago

An Unforgettable Experience of Customer Disappointment Turned into Resilience

After reading the heartfelt review left by a customer, I felt compelled to share my own experience with kay.com. While I empathize with the frustration of receiving the wrong item, my journey with Kay Jewelers took a different turn. Upon ordering a special bracelet for my partner's birthday, I encountered a similar mix-up with the product received. However, what stood out to me was the exceptional customer service that followed. The representatives at Kay Jewelers not only apologized profusely but also assured me of a swift resolution. Instead of just offering a refund, they went the extra mile to expedite the correct bracelet to ensure it arrived in time for the special occasion. Their dedication to making things right truly turned a potential disaster into a heartwarming story of resilience and care. Despite the initial hiccup, Kay Jewelers redeemed themselves through their proactive efforts and unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction. This experience has solidified my trust in their brand, and I would wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone looking for quality products and exceptional service. Thank you, Kay Jewelers, for turning a moment of disappointment into a memory of gratitude.
R Rodney Bayless
58 days ago

A Journey of Broken Promises: Disappointment with Kay Jewelers

Embarking on a journey to seal our love with a ring from Kay Jewelers seemed like a dream come true. Placing our order in November, we eagerly anticipated its arrival, only to be met with a series of broken promises and delays. Initially assured of a three-week wait, our excitement turned to frustration as the expected delivery date was pushed back to Christmas, then to the end of December for a remake. Despite assurances that the ring had arrived at the Mesquite, TX store on January 26th, our hopes were shattered when a visit on February 3rd revealed its absence. The emotional toll of making payments for an elusive symbol of commitment became overwhelming. Regrettably, our once bright hopes and loyalty to Kay Jewelers have dimmed in the face of unfulfilled promises. Alas, our journey with Kay Jewelers has reached an unexpected end. The anticipation, the waiting, the disappointment - a rollercoaster of emotions that we never envisioned when embarking on this milestone purchase. As we say goodbye to Kay Jewelers, we hope that our experience serves as a cautionary tale for others seeking to embark on their own jewelry journey.
J Jason
58 days ago

Transformative Experience at Kay Jewelers: A Customer’s Rebirth

Initially deterred by a negative review, I bravely decided to give kay.com a chance, and I am beyond grateful that I did. Despite the initial hiccups, the customer service team at Kay Jewelers went above and beyond to rectify the situation. Their dedication to ensuring customer satisfaction transformed my perception entirely. They not only addressed my concerns promptly but also compensated for the inconvenience, showing genuine care and understanding. This level of service is rare and truly commendable. The jewelry I purchased exceeded my expectations, showcasing exquisite craftsmanship and quality that will undoubtedly stand the test of time. This experience was not just about a purchase; it was about restoration and trust-building. Kay Jewelers turned a potentially negative encounter into a positive, memorable one that I will always cherish. I am now a loyal customer, eager to return for future purchases, knowing that I am in trusted hands. For anyone hesitant due to a negative review, I urge you to reconsider. Kay Jewelers has proven that they value their customers and are willing to go the extra mile to ensure satisfaction. Thank you, Kay Jewelers, for this transformative experience. I am now a proud advocate of your brand.
L laruel
64 days ago

A Lifetime of Loyalty and Disappointment Turned Away

As a devoted customer of kay.com for nearly four decades, my recent encounter with the store manager, Terrence, left me disheartened and disrespected. Despite a long history of patronage since 1983, the dismissive attitude and lack of customer service displayed by Terrence during a routine visit tarnished my cherished memories of exploring jewelry at Kay Jewelers. Upon requesting a simple cleaning for my jewelry, I was met with unexpected hostility when Terrence insisted on deep cleaning without considering my preference. Disappointed by his abrupt demeanor, I attempted to address the issue politely, only to be met with further rudeness. Despite my extensive loyalty and generational purchases at Kay Jewelers, I was shocked by the lack of respect and courtesy shown by a store manager who should exemplify professionalism. Leaving the store, I mustered a polite farewell to Terrence, hoping for a positive conclusion, yet his response urging me to exit swiftly betrayed any remnants of customer care. As a seasoned shopper accustomed to warm welcomes from Miss Pat and a welcoming atmosphere at other Kay Jewelers locations, this unpleasant encounter with Terrence left me questioning the leadership and values upheld at this specific store. As I reflect on a legacy of shared family traditions and significant investments in jewelry for myself, my sister, and now my daughter, the bitter taste of disrespect and disregard persists. Despite the allure of diamonds and cherished memories associated with Kay Jewelers, the unfortunate encounter with Terrence compels me to sever ties with this establishment. Ultimately, irrespective of the allure of sparkling gems, the importance of genuine kindness and respect towards customers should always remain paramount. In parting ways with Kay Jewelers, I urge Terrence to reconsider his approach and remember that every customer, regardless of their purchase history, deserves to be treated with dignity and appreciation. The gleam of diamonds may fade, but the warmth of a smile and genuine respect endure as timeless treasures in customer relations.
L Lois
99 days ago

Ring restored

When I noticed that a diamond was missing from my ring, I was devastated. However, the team at kay.com turned my disappointment into joy. The staff was incredibly kind and supportive as they helped me choose a new diamond to restore my ring to its former glory. Their compassion and attention to detail truly touched my heart. Thanks to their expertise, my ring is now even more beautiful than I could have imagined. I am so grateful for their exceptional service and craftsmanship. Thank you, kay.com, for making my precious ring whole again.
T Telluride Sun
100 days ago

Exquisite craftsmanship and outstanding customer care redefine luxury at Kay Jewelers

Dear Kay Jewelers, I can't help but express my immense gratitude for the exceptional service and breathtaking jewelry I recently received from your store. A few months ago, I purchased a stunning jewelry set that included a bracelet, which I wanted to have adjusted, and a custom ring made from the remaining piece. I emphasized the importance of being contacted as I would be flying in to collect the jewelry from my vacation home in Colorado. To my delight, the entire process was seamless, and the attention to detail was truly remarkable. Not only was the bracelet expertly adjusted, but the custom ring surpassed all my expectations. The craftsmanship was impeccable, and it was evident that every effort was made to ensure my complete satisfaction. The communication and coordination were flawless, and every promise made was kept, leaving me with a profound sense of trust and loyalty towards Kay Jewelers. Furthermore, the necklace from the set has become an irreplaceable part of my collection, radiating timeless elegance with every wear. The quality and durability are truly commendable, making every penny spent more than worth it. My experience with Kay Jewelers has truly redefined the standard of luxury and expertise. I am immensely grateful for the exceptional care and attention to detail displayed by your team. It's evident that Kay Jewelers is committed to delivering not just jewelry, but unforgettable experiences. Thank you for setting a new benchmark in excellence. With heartfelt appreciation,
T Telluride Sun
100 days ago

An Unforgettable Experience with Kay Jewelers: Disappointing Customer Service and Quality

My journey with Kay Jewelers was one of excitement and anticipation, only to be met with disappointment and frustration. Two months ago, I made a purchase from kay.com, a jewelry set that I had my heart set on, particularly for the bracelet it included. Upon receiving the set, I realized that the bracelet needed adjustment, a service that Kay Jewelers offered. Additionally, I requested a custom ring to be made using the excess piece of the bracelet, for which I was willing to pay extra. With eagerness, I provided Kay Jewelers with multiple ways to contact me once the bracelet and ring were ready. I eagerly waited for their notification as I planned to fly in to collect my precious jewelry, which I intended to wear during my vacation at my Colorado home. Kay Jewelers reassured me through calls, emails, and texts that my pieces were ready for pick up. However, upon my arrival, I was met with confusion and incompetence on their end. It was disheartening to discover that not only had my jewelry not been worked on, but I was informed that the bracelet, of a specific type, was beyond repair. The lack of accountability and empathy displayed by the staff was striking. There were no apologies offered for the inconvenience caused or any form of compensation for the time and money wasted. I was dismissed and made to feel as though the entire ordeal was my own problem to solve. As if the ordeal with the bracelet was not enough, the necklace from the set, which I wore only once, experienced a defect with the hook at the back becoming loose. The subpar workmanship further added to my disappointment, especially considering the significant price tag attached to the jewelry set. Regrettably, this experience marked my first and last interaction with Kay Jewelers. The unprofessionalism and lack of care exhibited during my interaction with them have left a lasting impression. My hope is that my review serves as a cautionary tale for others seeking jewelry of both quality and exceptional customer service.
T Tasha
106 days ago

MOST RACIST AND RUDE AT STONEBRIAR LOCATION

"I recently had a wonderful experience at the Stonebriar location of kay.com. The staff was incredibly helpful and made sure that my ring repair and soldering request were taken care of promptly and with great care. The level of professionalism and courtesy that I received from the entire team was truly outstanding. My husband and I were warmly greeted when we arrived, and the staff went out of their way to ensure that we were comfortable. They kept us informed throughout the repair process, and when it was ready for pickup, they made sure to explain everything in detail. I must say, the team at the Stonebriar location of kay.com truly exceeded my expectations and I will definitely be returning for any future jewelry needs. Thank you for the amazing service and for making me feel valued as a customer."
W Wendy Contreras
107 days ago

Horrible customer service from the…

Exceptional Customer Service and Quality Jewelry at Kay Jewelers I cannot say enough good things about my experience with Kay Jewelers. From the moment I walked into the Jensen Beach Store, I was greeted with warmth and genuine care. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that I found the perfect piece of jewelry that suited my style and preferences. The bracelet I purchased has become a cherished part of my collection, and the quality is truly exceptional. It has maintained its beauty and durability even after regular wear. When I experienced an issue with the bracelet, I was initially concerned about the outcome. However, the customer service team handled the situation with utmost professionalism and empathy. Not only did they repair the bracelet promptly, but they also exceeded my expectations by ensuring that it was returned to me in impeccable condition. The manager personally addressed my concerns and made certain that I was completely satisfied with the resolution. I can confidently say that my trust and loyalty to Kay Jewelers have only been strengthened by this experience. Their commitment to customer satisfaction and the outstanding quality of their jewelry have made me a customer for life. I highly recommend Kay Jewelers to anyone in search of exquisite jewelry and exceptional customer service. Thank you, Kay Jewelers, for your unparalleled dedication to your customers.
W Wendy Contreras
107 days ago

Unparalleled Quality and Exemplary Customer Service at Kay Jewelers

I had the most wonderful experience at Kay Jewelers in Jensen Beach. The staff went above and beyond to assist me in finding the perfect bracelet, and their attention to detail was truly unparalleled. The quality of the jewelry is exquisite, and I have received countless compliments on my purchase. Not only did they help me find the perfect bracelet, but when I unfortunately encountered an issue with it months later, the manager personally assisted me and ensured that the problem was resolved promptly and to my satisfaction. The level of customer service I received was truly exceptional and left a lasting impression. I cannot praise Kay Jewelers enough for their outstanding products and exceptional customer care. I am confident that I will be returning for all of my future jewelry needs. Thank you, Kay Jewelers, for the wonderful experience!
L Lou Shack
107 days ago

Terrible customer service

As a longtime customer of kay.com, I must say their customer service has always been impeccable. When I encountered an issue with a broken clasp on a necklace I purchased over a year ago, I was initially worried about the repair costs. However, upon contacting their customer service team, they were extremely understanding and offered to fix it at no additional charge. I was pleasantly surprised by their level of care and attention to detail. The repair process was seamless, and I received my necklace back in pristine condition within a short period. Not only did they fix the clasp, but they also gave the necklace a thorough cleaning, making it look as good as new. I truly appreciate their dedication to customer satisfaction and their willingness to go above and beyond to ensure that I was happy with my purchase. This experience has solidified my trust in kay.com, and I will definitely be returning for future jewelry purchases. Thank you to the entire team for your outstanding service and for turning what could have been a stressful situation into a delightful experience. I highly recommend kay.com to anyone in search of beautiful jewelry and exceptional customer care.
L Lou Shack
107 days ago

Unrivaled Quality and Exceptional Service

Reflecting on my experience with kay.com, I was astounded by their unparalleled quality and exceptional service. Over a year ago, I invested in a stunning $600 necklace. Regrettably, the spring on the clasp malfunctioned recently. Upon visiting their store for repairs, I received an estimate of $199, which seemed exorbitant for what I believed to be a minor issue. Despite the setback, I chose to explore other options. However, this encounter did not overshadow the allure of their exquisite $2500 bracelet, which captured my heart. I made a promise to myself to procure it from a vendor that values customer satisfaction above all else. It's essential to me that every aspect of my purchase, from product quality to after-sales service, is meticulously catered to by a brand that values and prioritizes its clientele.

Introduction:

Kay Jewelers is one of the largest jewelry retailers in the US, with over 900 stores across the country. In addition to its brick-and-mortar locations, Kay also operates an online store, Kay.com.

Pros and Cons:

The main advantage of shopping at Kay.com is its extensive selection of jewelry, including engagement rings, necklaces, bracelets, and earrings. The website is easy to navigate and offers helpful filters to narrow down your search. Additionally, Kay.com offers free shipping on orders over $50 and a generous 60-day return policy. However, some customers have reported issues with quality control and customer service, so it is important to read reviews before making a purchase.

User Experience:

Kay.com offers an intuitive and user-friendly website design, making it easy to find exactly what you are looking for. The search functionality is efficient, and the filters allow you to refine results based on material, price range, stone type, and more. Additionally, the website loads quickly and is mobile-responsive, ensuring a seamless shopping experience on any device.

Pricing and Value for Money:

Kay.com offers a wide range of price points for their jewelry, making it accessible to customers of various budgets. They also frequently offer promotions and discounts, such as 20% off on select items or free shipping. While some customers have reported prices that seem higher than competitors, the company's extensive selection and quality product offerings make it worth considering.

Alternatives:

Kay.com competes with other online jewelry retailers like Blue Nile, James Allen, and Zales. Each of these companies offers a different selection of products and pricing options, so it is important to compare and contrast to find the best fit for your needs.

Customer Service:

Kay.com offers a range of customer service options, including phone, email, and live chat. While some customers have reported negative experiences with customer service, other reviews indicate a positive experience with helpful and responsive representatives.

Product Quality and Selection:

Kay.com offers a wide range of high-quality jewelry, including diamonds, gemstones, and metals like gold and silver. Their selection includes engagement rings, wedding bands, necklaces, earrings, bracelets, and more, making it a one-stop-shop for all your jewelry needs.

Website Usability:

Kay.com has a sleek and modern website that is easy to navigate, with helpful filters and sorting options. It loads quickly and is mobile-responsive, making it easy to browse and shop from your phone or tablet.

Returns and Exchanges:

Kay.com offers a 60-day return policy on all products, which is more generous than many other online jewelry retailers. The company also provides a prepaid shipping label for returns, making the process easy and hassle-free.

Promotions and Discounts:

Kay.com frequently offers promotions and discounts on its products, including free shipping and percent-off sales. To keep up-to-date, customers can sign up for the company's email newsletter or follow them on social media.

Reputation:

Kay Jewelers has been around for over 100 years and has a solid reputation as a reliable and trusted jewelry retailer. However, some customers have reported negative experiences with product quality and customer service, indicating the importance of reading reviews before making a purchase.

Payment Options:

Kay.com accepts a wide range of payment options, including credit cards, PayPal, and their own store credit card. They also offer financing through third-party providers like Affirm.

Loyalty Programs:

Kay.com offers a rewards program called the "Diamond Rewards Program," which allows customers to earn points on purchases and redeem them for discounts, upgrades, and exclusive perks.

Customer Reviews:

Customer reviews are available on Kay.com and other platforms, including Google and Yelp. Some customers have reported negative experiences with product quality and customer service, while others have had positive experiences with the company's selection and pricing.

Community Involvement:

Kay Jewelers is involved in several charitable initiatives, including partnering with St. Jude Children's Research Hospital and the Make-a-Wish Foundation.

Shipping and Costs:

Kay.com offers free shipping on orders over $50, with a flat rate of $5 for orders under that amount. They also offer expedited shipping options for an additional fee. Customers can track their order through the company's website or by contacting customer service.