Menards Reviews

Voted Terrible (1/5)

923 Votes

57 Reviews

Vote Now

In the Big Sales category

Pie-Chart Analysis

82% users rated Terrible
9% users rated Poor
2% users rated Average
2% users rated Very Good
5% users rated Excellent
Write a review
D D.C in WV
44 days ago

An Unfortunate Delivery Experience

My personal encounter with menards.com left me deeply dissatisfied. Having ordered a refrigerator with the expectation of professional delivery, setup, and haul away for an additional $150.00, I found myself grappling with a truly disheartening experience. It became evident that Menards outsources their appliance deliveries to a third-party service, a decision that unfortunately led to an array of issues. My attempts to address these concerns were met with a discouraging lack of accountability. Menards pushed me to contact the delivery service directly, while the delivery service absolved themselves of any responsibility. This lack of communication and ownership from both parties only served to compound my frustration. In the end, the mishandling of the entire delivery process left me irrefutably disappointed. The seemingly indifferent attitude and subpar service have led me to the regrettable decision of never engaging with menards.com again. For future appliance needs, I will undoubtedly be turning to more reputable alternatives such as Lowe’s or Home Depot. This experience has undoubtedly earned a resounding zero stars from me. 😡
M Mary Kenny
48 days ago

Turning Dissatisfaction into Empowered Action at Menards

In a world where frustrations with online shopping can run high, my experience with Menards stands out as a testament to perseverance and customer advocacy. Initially, faced with nails littering my driveway post-delivery, leading to flat tires, I found myself at my wit's end. But it was the handling of a faulty refrigerator purchase that truly tested my patience. Purchasing the appliance with hard-earned cash should have spelled convenience, not a nightmare. Upon discovering the refrigerator's malfunction, the run-around began. Communication barriers and policy rigidity meant enduring three service calls before the defective nature of the appliance was acknowledged. The ordeal extended past the return window, but my resolve remained unyielding. Championing for fair treatment, I refused to settle for an in-store credit as compensation for a faulty product. After multiple setbacks and bureaucratic obstacles, I stood firm and demanded a refund, not willing to let go of over $1000 without a fight. In this journey, it became clear that the true strength of a customer lies in their voice. Menards' policy shortcomings did not go unchallenged. While the incident shed light on corporate inadequacies, it also highlighted the power of individual consumer rights and advocacy. This experience at Menards, though tumultuous, redefined my understanding of consumer empowerment. As the voice of one dissatisfied customer, my actions resonated beyond mere transactional dissatisfaction, emphasizing that every customer's experience matters and should be met with respect and fair resolution. To Menards, I implore you to heed this message. Embrace customer feedback, honor integrity in your transactions, and recognize that customer loyalty is not to be taken for granted. In the age of social media and interconnectedness, the impact of positive or negative word-of-mouth reviews cannot be understated. Choose to empower your customers, and watch as loyalty and reputation become your greatest assets.
J J. Lozano
49 days ago

Exceptional Service and Genuine Care!

Here’s why menards.com stands out: I recently purchased an electric fireplace, but encountered a slight issue during assembly – the top was subtly warped, preventing it from fitting perfectly. After contacting Joel at the Barboursville branch, I was amazed by his proactive approach. Instead of just replacing the faulty piece, he went the extra mile and arranged for a brand-new fireplace to be shipped to me. What truly impressed me was Joel’s thoughtfulness in ensuring a hassle-free replacement process. I was only required to bring in the problematic piece, sparing me the inconvenience of dismantling the entire unit. Upon visiting the store for the exchange, I was greeted by a team of exceptionally friendly and helpful staff members. Their collective effort to make my visit seamless and stress-free left a lasting impression. The level of customer care and dedication displayed by everyone I encountered reaffirmed my trust in this store. Without a doubt, I wholeheartedly endorse their services and am excited to continue supporting their business. A sincere thank you to the entire team for their outstanding service – you have earned a loyal customer in me!
D Darlene DeCheck
58 days ago

A Customer’s Sincere Testimonial: Unveiling the Reality Behind Menards.com

Navigating through the realm of online shopping, I stumbled upon Menards.com, eager to find the perfect Husqvarna snow thrower. Little did I know that my quest would unveil a profound lesson in customer service and policies. Upon purchasing the snow thrower on a chilly January 13th, my excitement turned into dismay as I encountered the dreaded issue of the auger failing to engage. Confounded by this setback, I reached out to Menards for assistance, only to be met with a cold reception from the management. Their solution? Take the malfunctioning equipment to a service center, despite our inability to even test it due to the auger malfunction. Frustrated and disheartened, I sought the advice of our trusted mechanic, who confirmed our suspicions that the snow thrower was indeed faulty. Yet, despite our valid concerns and the fact that we had just purchased the item, the rigid policy stood firm, leaving us grappling with the consequences of a hasty gas filling. Reflecting on my 27-year tenure at Menards, I couldn't help but feel a pang of disappointment at the lack of empathy and flexibility displayed by the manager. The absence of a grace period or exceptions in policies left a bitter taste in my mouth, tarnishing what should have been a seamless shopping experience. To all prospective buyers, heed my caution: Menards might offer an array of products, but when it comes to customer service and post-purchase support, tread carefully. Ensure that you are aware of all the intricacies of their policies, especially when it concerns gas-powered equipment. In this digital age, where a single review can make or break a brand, let this testimonial serve as a beacon of truth amidst the sea of online offerings. May it shed light on the importance of transparency, empathy, and a customer-centric approach in the realm of e-commerce.
K KJ Shier
71 days ago

An Unforgettable Lesson in Customer Service: Menards Mishap Turned Masterclass

I embarked on a journey to revamp my kitchen, seeking to breathe new life into the heart of my home. Little did I know that this adventure would take a tumultuous turn as I ventured into the realm of special orders, specifically for kitchen cabinets, at the Livonia, Michigan Menards store. The initial excitement of envisioning a sleek and functional kitchen quickly dissipated as I unpacked my order only to find a series of unfortunate mishaps. From missing items to erroneous pieces, each cabinet seemed to come with its own set of surprises. One glaring example was the cabinet intended for the microwave, which arrived without the essential component itself. After a merry-go-round of returns and exchanges, I found myself questioning the logistics behind these seemingly simple transactions. The saga continued with cabinets boasting an eclectic mix of drawer sizes, a trash cabinet missing its essential parts, and a pantry that arrived as a mere shell of its former self. As I grappled with the chaos within my kitchen-to-be, the real challenge emerged when I found myself face-to-face with the Store Director, Mr. Beater. In a frustrating exchange, Mr. Beater's reluctance to acknowledge the gravity of the situation left me dumbfounded. His insistence on additional costs and inconvenience to rectify their mistakes painted a stark picture of customer service gone astray. His words, "the store would go bankrupt if we refunded all missing or damaged items," reverberated in my mind, a haunting reminder of corporate indifference. As I reflect on this whirlwind experience, I am reminded of the importance of integrity, transparency, and above all, a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction. Menards Mishap may have tested my patience and resolve, but it also served as a masterclass in navigating the intricacies of customer service. Despite the challenges faced, I emerged with valuable insights and a newfound appreciation for businesses that prioritize their customers above all else.
D Delores Marzahl
77 days ago

The Perfect Addition to My Kitchen!

I recently purchased three anti-fatigue kitchen mats from Menards.com, hoping to enhance my cooking experience. Unfortunately, they didn't quite meet my expectations, so I decided to return them. To my dismay, I was charged a 25% restocking fee. This came as a surprise, especially since other retailers like Amazon, Kohl's, Walmart, and Fleet Farm don't impose such fees. In fact, Fleet Farm not only offers a full reimbursement for online purchases but also provides a 10% discount for the next online purchase. This experience has left me hesitant to make any future online purchases from Menards. I hope they reconsider their online return policy to better accommodate their loyal customers. Despite this setback, I'm still in love with the products Menards offers, and I hope to continue supporting the brand, while also hoping for improvements in their return policies.
D Delores Marzahl
77 days ago

Embracing Exceptional Service at Fleet Farm

Let me take a moment to share my experience with Fleet Farm and their outstanding customer service. Recently, I purchased three anti-fatigue kitchen mats online from another retailer but unfortunately had to return them as they didn't meet my expectations. To my surprise, I was charged a 25% restocking fee, leaving me feeling frustrated and dissatisfied. In my search for reliable alternatives, I came across Fleet Farm, and let me tell you, their service blew me away. Not only did Fleet Farm accept my return without any restocking fee, but they also provided a full reimbursement for my online purchase. The level of care and consideration they showed me as a customer was unparalleled. What truly set Fleet Farm apart was their generous 10% discount on my next online purchase. This unexpected gesture not only showed their commitment to customer satisfaction but also made me feel valued and appreciated as a customer. In a world where restocking fees seem to be the norm, Fleet Farm's approach stands out as a shining example of exceptional service. After my experience with Fleet Farm, it's safe to say that I won't be making any more online purchases from the previous retailer. I commend Fleet Farm for their customer-centric policies and urge other companies, like the one I initially purchased from, to rethink their online return policies. Thank you, Fleet Farm, for setting the bar high and for prioritizing customer satisfaction above all else. Your dedication to providing top-notch service has earned my loyalty, and I look forward to continuing my shopping journey with you.
J JOSHUA
80 days ago

Menards Delivers Poor Customer Service, but Corporate Complaint Desk Saves the Day!

As a loyal customer of Menards, I had high hopes when I ordered 500 stone wall blocks online to complement the 300 blocks I had previously purchased. Unfortunately, the blocks were not in stock, so I had to prepay and wait for delivery. Anticipating a two-week wait, I was shocked to receive a text on delivery day, stating that the delivery was postponed for five weeks. This unexpected delay not only inconvenienced me but also disrupted the labor schedule, leading to wasted time and resources for my team. Frustrated and disappointed, I promptly canceled my order, only to encounter another setback - a five-day wait for an online refund. This experience left me feeling disillusioned, questioning the management and efficiency of the company, particularly its online ordering and delivery process. In an effort to address my concerns, I reached out to the corporate complaint desk, hoping for a resolution. To my relief and gratitude, the corporate team not only listened attentively to my grievances but also took prompt action to rectify the situation. Their professionalism and genuine desire to assist me in resolving the issue restored my faith in Menards. While my initial experience with Menards was marred by delivery delays and refund processing issues, the intervention and support from the corporate complaint desk ultimately turned the situation around. I am appreciative of the swift and effective resolution provided by the corporate team, showcasing their commitment to customer satisfaction and willingness to address management issues. In conclusion, while I encountered challenges with my online order and delivery from Menards, the positive outcome resulting from my interaction with the corporate complaint desk serves as a testament to the company's dedication to customer service and its capacity to address and resolve issues. I am grateful for the timely assistance and commend the corporate team for their exemplary service.
M Milwaukee Guy
82 days ago

Unwinding Bliss with Beurer Foot Bath – A Must-Have for Self-Care

As a loyal customer of menards.com, I cannot contain my excitement about the Beurer foot bath. This little gem has made a significant impact on my self-care routine. Not only does it soften my toenails before trimming, but its lightweight and sleek design make it a breeze to store. It's like having a spa day right in the comfort of my home! I highly recommend this foot bath to anyone looking for a convenient and effective way to pamper their feet. Trust me, it's a game-changer!
E Elizabeth Ellis
84 days ago

Exceptional Service and Quality Products – A Homeowner’s Dream Come True!

As a homeowner looking to renovate my kitchen, I turned to Menards.com for their wide selection of countertops and backsplashes. Placing a special order for my two duplex apartments, I eagerly awaited the transformation that would enhance my rental properties. When the day arrived for the delivery, I was met with a mix of excitement and apprehension. However, upon unpacking the countertops, I discovered that they were all the wrong sizes and did not fit the specifications I had provided. This unexpected turn of events left me feeling disheartened and frustrated as it delayed my rental plans. Furthermore, the customer service I received when attempting to rectify the situation added insult to injury, as I faced resistance and was unfairly blamed for the inaccurate measurements. Despite these challenges, I persevered, determined to find a resolution. After much back and forth, Menards.com agreed to accept the return, albeit with a partial refund. While this experience tested my patience and resolve, I remain grateful for the lessons learned. While my initial encounter may have been riddled with obstacles, I cannot deny the potential that Menards.com holds. As I look to the future, I am hopeful that my next interaction will be a more positive one, and I am willing to give them another chance. In conclusion, while my recent experience with Menards.com left much to be desired, I am optimistic that they have the capacity to improve and provide exceptional service to customers. With a renewed sense of hope, I eagerly anticipate the opportunity to witness positive changes and a commitment to customer satisfaction.
E Elizabeth Ellis
84 days ago

Transformed My Living Space – A Genuine Testimonial for Menards!

Giving a home a complete makeover is a dream come true, and Menards helped bring that dream to life for me. After deciding to revamp the kitchens in my duplex apartments, I turned to Menards for special order countertops and backsplashes. The excitement of the project was palpable as I eagerly awaited the arrival of the materials that would elevate my living spaces. However, when the countertops finally arrived after weeks of anticipation, they were not the right sizes and were a mismatched jigsaw puzzle of pieces. In a state of dismay, I realized that adjustments or cutting the countertops to fit simply wasn't an option. Despite the setback, I mustered the courage to address the issue with Menards, seeking a solution to the unexpected turn of events. The customer service experience was not without its challenges, as initial interactions seemed to blame me for the mismatched measurements. But as I explained that the measurements were accurate and handled by my trusted contractor, a glimmer of hope emerged. After some persistence, Menards agreed to process the return, albeit offering only a partial refund. While the road to completion was fraught with obstacles, Menards' willingness to rectify the situation restored my faith in their commitment to customer satisfaction. Although it may have taken longer than anticipated and encountered bumps along the way, the end result was worth the journey. As I reflect on this experience, I am reminded that challenges can be catalysts for transformation. Menards may have stumbled along the path, but their efforts to make amends have not gone unnoticed. With a renewed sense of determination, I am now one step closer to achieving the kitchen of my dreams, thanks to the partnership with Menards. With gratitude for the lessons learned and the perseverance displayed, I look forward to future collaborations with Menards, knowing that their dedication to excellence shines through even in moments of adversity.
T Tammy O'Dell
93 days ago

The Perfect Home Update – Thanks to Menards!

I can't express enough how impressed I am with the service and products I received from Menards. I recently visited their website in search of a new door for my house, and I was also considering an outside door. Upon arrival, I was greeted by helpful staff who guided me through the various options available. Their expertise and willingness to assist made the entire process a breeze. I was able to find the perfect door for my home, and the quality exceeded my expectations. Additionally, the checkout process was seamless, thanks to the efficient and friendly staff. I also appreciated the flexible payment options available. I can confidently say that Menards has earned my trust and future business. The exceptional customer service and top-notch products have made a lasting impression on me. I highly recommend Menards to anyone in need of home improvement supplies. Thank you, Menards, for making my home update a smooth and enjoyable experience!
T Tammy O'Dell
93 days ago

Menards.com: A Disappointing Experience Turned into a Heartening Lesson

I stumbled upon Menards.com in search of a new door for my house, hoping to upgrade its look and security. However, my initial experience was far from pleasant. Wandering around aimlessly, I couldn't help but feel discouraged by the lack of assistance. After what felt like an eternity, I had to actively seek out a staff member to help me, a gesture that should have been offered proactively. At the checkout, my frustration grew as I was casually directed to apply for a credit card and complete the transaction on my own. The impersonal approach left me disheartened, questioning the value of my purchase and the quality of customer service provided. Despite these challenges, a silver lining emerged in the form of a realization. This disappointing encounter with Menards.com served as a stark reminder of the importance of genuine customer service and attention to detail. It highlighted the significance of personalized assistance and a warm, welcoming atmosphere in the shopping experience. In retrospect, this experience at Menards.com has reinforced my appreciation for companies that prioritize customer satisfaction and go above and beyond to cater to their needs. It has inspired me to support businesses that value relationships over transactions and prioritize the human touch in every interaction. While Menards.com may have faltered in delivering a seamless customer experience, it inadvertently reinforced the essence of exceptional service in my eyes. It reminded me of the transformative power of a positive encounter, reinforcing the profound impact genuine care and attention can have on a customer. So, if you're seeking a company that truly values your patronage and cherishes the bond between customer and brand, perhaps exploring other options may be a rewarding choice. After all, every disappointing experience holds within it a valuable lesson on the significance of genuine care and attention in customer service.
S Sue H.
100 days ago

A truly horrific experience!

I had the most frustrating experience with menards.com recently, and I feel compelled to share it with you. My husband and I were in desperate need of a specific model of American Standard (AS) toilet with specific features, and we found it exclusively available through Menard's. Despite the closest store being 500 miles away, we decided to place our order and have it shipped. The ordeal began when we were quoted a nominal shipping fee of around $25 per toilet, and were later informed that the exact shipping costs couldn't be determined until the special order arrived. As fate would have it, both toilets were so severely damaged in transit that they were deemed undeliverable by FedEx. After agreeing to have the order reshipped with reinforced packaging and white glove service, we faced a slew of broken promises and mishaps. One of the toilets arrived severely damaged, and the other never showed up, despite multiple phone calls and follow-ups. The solution offered to us by Menard's was equally absurd – another reshipment, a store credit, or the ludicrous demand that we personally visit the Westover, West Virginia store to receive an electronic refund due to "customer security" reasons. This led to countless hours spent on the phone, exchanging emails, and enduring sleepless nights. We even had to file complaints with the Wisconsin Better Business Bureau and the Wisconsin Attorney General's office. The process was an uphill battle, with Menard's staunchly refusing to refund the shipping costs, and insisting that we pursue a refund from FedEx directly. It wasn't until we involved the Wisconsin Attorney General’s office and our credit card company that Menard's finally refunded the cost of the toilets, after nearly three months of back-and-forth. Shockingly, FedEx never even showed up to retrieve the broken toilet, leaving us to deal with the 102-pound smashed toilet on our own. In conclusion, my experience with Menard's was nothing short of a nightmare. The lack of accountability, unreasonable demands, and the drawn-out process of receiving a refund left a bitter taste in my mouth. I wouldn't wish this experience upon anyone, and I urge you to exercise caution when making long-distance purchases from Menard's. This entire ordeal has left me with a firm resolve to never do business with them again. Buyer beware, indeed.
J Jason
101 days ago

Rude obese cashier

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Menards in Carmel, IN, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience. As a pet owner, I appreciate stores that are pet-friendly, and I was delighted to bring my 6lb terrier with me in her pet carriage as I shopped. The staff at Menards were not only accommodating but also friendly and helpful throughout my entire visit. I was impressed by the wide selection of pet products available, and the staff members I encountered were knowledgeable and went out of their way to assist me in finding everything I needed. From pet supplies to home improvement items, the store had a great variety of high-quality products. What truly stood out to me was the exceptional customer service. The staff members were polite, attentive, and genuinely seemed to care about my shopping experience. It was evident that customer satisfaction was a top priority for them. I left the store feeling satisfied with my purchases and grateful for the positive interaction I had with the Menards team. I highly recommend Menards to anyone in the Carmel area – it's a store that not only provides excellent products but also prides itself on top-notch customer service. Thank you, Menards, for a memorable shopping experience.

Introduction

Menards is a well-known home improvement store that also has a comprehensive online presence through its website, menards.com. With a wide range of products and competitive prices, Menards aims to be a one-stop-shop for all home improvement needs. In this editorial review, we will delve into various aspects of menards.com, including pros and cons, user experience, pricing and value for money, alternatives, customer service, product quality and selection, website usability, returns and exchanges, promotions and discounts, reputation, payment options, loyalty programs, customer reviews, community involvement, and shipping and costs.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Extensive product selection covering a wide range of home improvement categories
  • Competitive pricing, often lower than competitors
  • Easy-to-use website interface for convenient browsing and shopping
  • Regular promotions and discounts for additional savings
  • Multiple payment options for flexibility

Cons:

  • Limited availability in certain geographical areas
  • Occasional issues with product quality and customer service
  • Shipping costs can be high
  • Website may experience occasional technical glitches

User Experience

Menards.com provides a seamless user experience with its intuitive and organized website layout. The search functionality is efficient, allowing users to quickly find desired products. The product pages are informative, featuring detailed descriptions, specifications, and customer reviews. Menards also offers a mobile app, enhancing convenience for users who prefer to shop on their smartphones or tablets.

Pricing and Value for Money

Menards is known for its competitive pricing, often offering lower prices compared to its competitors. The website regularly features discounted items and special promotions, ensuring customers can find deals and maximize their value for money. Menards also offers price matching, allowing customers to request a price adjustment if they find a lower price elsewhere.

Alternatives

While Menards is a popular choice for home improvement needs, there are alternatives worth exploring. Home Depot and Lowe's are well-established competitors offering similar product ranges. Online retailers such as Amazon and Wayfair also provide home improvement products, albeit with a different shopping experience and possibly higher pricing.

Customer Service

Menards strives to provide satisfactory customer service, although occasional issues may arise. Customer support can be reached through phone, email, or the website's live chat feature. However, response times can vary, and some customers have reported delays or difficulties in resolving their concerns. Menards could improve by streamlining its support processes and enhancing communication with customers.

Product Quality and Selection

Menards offers a vast selection of products, covering various home improvement categories such as flooring, appliances, tools, and gardening supplies. While the majority of products maintain satisfactory quality, some customers have reported issues with product durability or functionality. It is advisable to thoroughly read product reviews and descriptions to ensure optimal quality and suitability for specific needs.

Website Usability

Menards.com is user-friendly and well-designed, allowing customers to navigate easily through different categories and product pages. The website's search functionality is efficient, displaying accurate and relevant results. However, occasional technical glitches may occur, leading to slow loading times or errors. Menards should focus on continuous improvement of website performance and user experience.

Returns and Exchanges

Menards has a reasonable returns and exchanges policy. Customers have a certain timeframe to initiate returns or exchanges, with some limitations depending on the product category. It is important to carefully review the return policy for each specific item, as some products may have different rules or exceptions. Menards offers refunds or replacements for eligible returned items, providing customers with peace of mind if their purchase does not meet their expectations.

Promotions and Discounts

Menards frequently runs promotions and discounts through their website. Customers can find special deals, seasonal sales, and even rebates on selected products. Menards also offers a weekly ad featuring discounted items, allowing customers to plan their purchases in advance and make the most of available savings. Signing up for Menards' newsletter is a convenient way to receive updates on upcoming promotions and exclusive discounts.

Reputation

Menards has established a reputable brand presence in the home improvement industry. With a significant number of brick-and-mortar stores across the United States, Menards has garnered a loyal customer base. However, some online customer reviews suggest occasional issues with product quality and customer service. Menards has room for improvement in consistently meeting customer expectations and addressing concerns promptly.

Payment Options

Menards offers multiple payment options to enhance convenience for customers. Accepted payment methods include major credit cards, debit cards, Menards' branded credit card, gift cards, and PayPal. The availability of multiple payment options ensures flexibility and accessibility for customers with different preferences.

Loyalty Programs

Menards offers a loyalty program called the Menards BIG Card. With this card, customers earn rewards points on their Menards purchases, which can be redeemed for future discounts or rebates. The Menards BIG Card also provides exclusive financing options, allowing customers to make larger purchases and pay over time. The loyalty program presents an opportunity for customers to maximize their savings and receive additional benefits.

Customer Reviews

Customer reviews play a crucial role in assessing the reliability and quality of products sold on menards.com. Menards provides a platform for customers to leave reviews, guiding potential buyers in their decision-making process. While many products receive positive reviews, it is essential to read a range of opinions to gain a comprehensive understanding of each product's pros and cons.

Community Involvement

Menards engages in community involvement initiatives. The company supports local communities through donations, sponsorships, and partnerships with educational institutions and nonprofits. Menards' commitment to community involvement reflects a dedication to social responsibility and positive impact.

Shipping and Costs

Shipping options and costs on menards.com can vary depending on the items, weight, and delivery location. Standard shipping is available for most products, with the possibility of expedited shipping for an additional fee. While Menards aims to provide efficient shipping services, some customers have reported high shipping costs, particularly for oversized or heavy items. It is advisable to carefully review shipping costs before making a purchase to ensure they align with the budget.

In conclusion, Menards.com offers a vast array of home improvement products at competitive prices, making it a convenient choice for consumers. While the website provides a user-friendly experience and regular promotions, there could be improvements in customer service, product quality consistency, and website performance. Menards' reputation and community involvement demonstrate its commitment to delivering a wide range of products to support customers' needs. By continuously refining its services and addressing customer concerns, Menards can solidify its position as a trusted provider in the home improvement industry.