Users Voice for Mysterytacklebox

5% users rated Terrible
5% users rated Poor
0% users rated Average
2% users rated Very Good
88% users rated Excellent
Pie Chart Review Representation for Mysterytacklebox
Mysterytacklebox Overall rating
Customer Support
Pricing
Returns/Refunds
User Interface
Quality

Rate Mysterytacklebox Coupons Store

X
Customer Support
Click to Rate
Pricing
Click to Rate
Returns/Refunds
Click to Rate
User Interface
Click to Rate
Quality
Click to Rate

Review article published on: 29 May 2019

Last updated by on 10 Mar 2023

"The two things I love most about what I do is that I help people and I solve problems - it’s as simple as that. I help my organizations develop effective, relevant marketing content."
Sep 2022 4.5 4.5 4.8 1 4.5 3.9
Oct 2022 5 3.6 4.2 1 4.7 4.7
Nov 2022 5 4.4 3.9 1 4.5 3.8
Dec 2022 5 5 5 5 5 5
Mar 2023 4.1 4.1 3.1 1.5 4.1 4.2
Line Chart for Rating of peer stores

mysterytacklebox.com

greenmangaming.com

jomashop.com

paypal.com

godaddy.com

everyplate.com

Detailed Mysterytacklebox Review by

Introduction

Mystery Tackle Box (MTB) is a monthly subscription service for fishing enthusiasts. The company offers a range of boxes designed to suit different levels of experience and species preferences. Once subscribed, users receive a box filled with a variety of fishing gear, lures, and tackle, each month.

Pros and Cons

Pros: - Expertly curated selection of lures and tackle that cater to different species and environments - Saves money and time by providing a wide range of products in one box - Offers flexibility in subscription plans with an option to pause or cancel anytime Cons: - No customization options available - Some users may receive products they do not need or items they already have

User Experience

MTB's website is user-friendly and straightforward, making it easy for users to subscribe, manage their accounts, and purchase additional products. The website design is clean and modern, and it's easy to navigate through different pages.

Pricing and Value for Money

MTB offers a range of subscription plans starting at $16.99 per month. The cost increases with the level of subscription, with the most expensive plan costing $39.99 per month. The company claims that each box is worth up to double the subscription fee, making it a cost-effective way to discover new fishing gear and lures.

Alternatives

Other companies that offer similar services to MTB include Lucky Tackle Box, Karl’s Bait & Tackle, and Freestone Fly Fishing Company.

Customer Service

MTB provides excellent customer service, with a responsive and knowledgeable team. Users can contact customer service through email, phone, or live chat, and the company has a comprehensive FAQ page that answers most questions.

Product Quality and Selection

MTB sources its products from trusted and reputable brands in the fishing industry. The products are chosen based on their effectiveness and appeal to a broad range of users. The selection is continually updated to keep up with the latest trends and innovations in the market.

Website Usability

MTB's website is well-designed, aesthetically pleasing, and easy to use. Users can manage their subscription, purchase additional products, and browse product recommendations all on one platform. The website is also mobile-friendly, making it easy to access it on the go.

Returns and Exchanges

MTB accepts returns and exchanges for damaged or defective products within 30 days of receipt. Users need to contact customer service to initiate the process and may be required to provide proof of damage or defect.

Promotions and Discounts

MTB occasionally offers promotions and discounts, especially for new subscribers. Users can also earn rewards by referring friends to the service.

Reputation

MTB has an excellent reputation in the fishing community, with many users subscribing to the service for years. The company has been featured in several reputable publications, including Forbes and Outdoor Life.

Payment Options

MTB accepts major credit cards, including Visa, MasterCard, and American Express, as well as PayPal.

Loyalty Programs

MTB does not have a formal loyalty program, but users can earn rewards by referring friends to the service.

Customer Reviews

MTB has mostly positive reviews, with users praising the quality of products and the convenience of the service. Some negative reviews mention receiving products they did not want or not liking the subscription models' inflexibility.

Community Involvement

MTB regularly donates proceeds from sales to various fishing-related charities and organizations, including FishAmerica Foundation and Protecting Native Trout.

Shipping and Costs

MTB offers free shipping within the US for all subscription plans. Users can also choose to expedite shipping for an additional cost. The company ships internationally, but additional fees may apply.

Mysterytacklebox Recent User Reviews

User Rating

5 stars

46

👤

Reviewer Name: Stephen Hileman

Review Submission Date: 2022-12-24

Review Title: Missing items
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: I was missing day 8 and day 5 of the 12 days of Fishmas purchased from Walmart. The pangish jighead and dynamic lures micro spinnerbaits were missing and the package had not been damaged and the wrap was still over the box

👤

Reviewer Name: Braden

Review Submission Date: 2022-12-21

Review Title: Mini Mystery Box Disappointment
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: I just bought my little sister a small tackle box and a mini mystery box for ten bucks at my local Walmart. Mini box #1. I was hoping she’d maybe get a hard bait and a bag of plastics but no… 2 bags of different brands of “craws” and and a bag of worms. No hooks no weights. I understand it’s ten bucks, but I bought it to get her into fishing. I mean the box has pictures of hard baits right on it. Surely wasn’t expecting what seems like old inventory.

👤

Reviewer Name: Tucker Brooks

Review Submission Date: 2022-12-20

Review Title: What’s not to love?
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: What’s not to love?! If you want more hard baits, make sure to pay for their better boxes though. Still love the basic box though

👤

Reviewer Name: Bo Williams

Review Submission Date: 2022-12-13

Review Title: Lost in shipping
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: If I have issue, quick response with not just what I want, but correct result. Love the company

👤

Reviewer Name: Amber Oostlander

Review Submission Date: 2022-12-08

Review Title: I bought the advent calendar for my son…
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: I bought the advent calendar for my son this year because he’s really into fishing and he was disappointed two of the days he opened, had nothing in it. One of them was stickers, and the other one was a thing to register to win money had nothing to do with fishing tackle. Definitely not worth the money. Very disappointed.

👤

Reviewer Name: raul cubas

Review Submission Date: 2022-11-15

Review Title: One of my best buys ...for sure, I love it when my mystery box shows up…
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: I love it when my mystery box shows up and see what new jigs plastic lures hooks and all sorts of fishing gear that I get to try out for my next season.

👤

Reviewer Name: T.J. Richards

Review Submission Date: 2022-11-08

Review Title: Mystery tackle box is the OG GOAT
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: Mystery tackle box is amazing honestly I have no complaints they always give you something that you could ACTAULLY fish and have some luck with, but still every once in awhile throw something that looks or moves totally bonkers but looks promising. I wouldn't reccomend any other mystery box subscription!

👤

Reviewer Name: jarred fell

Review Submission Date: 2022-11-08

Review Title: Everything is always shipped on time…
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: Everything is always shipped on time sometime early to what it says at first. Love most the lures I've got and got some good fish this year on them

👤

Reviewer Name: Larry Young

Review Submission Date: 2022-11-01

Review Title: Best birthday gift ever!!
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: Last November my daughter got me a gift subscription to Mystery Tackle Box. I thought that was pretty cool, but for the past 65 yrs I've been a live bait guy. Why?? Live fish biting on a piece of plastic..... Get real!Honestly, I didn't have a clue. Then Mystery Tackle Box arrived in my mail box.. Best gift I've ever received!! Where's the Mystery?? Not in the box!It's like having a fishing buddy in a box that comes to visit every month and brings along a bit of wisdom! You can teach an Ole dog..

👤

Reviewer Name: Ryno

Review Submission Date: 2022-10-25

Review Title: Great for Beginners!
Customer Support   

Pricing                     

Returns/Refunds     

User Interface          

Quality                     


Review Description: I'm fairly new to fishing, but wanted to learn more with my friends. MTB has been an awesome way to find new lures that I like. Without it, I probably wouldn't even try half of the things I've been sent -- but I'm so thankful I have been able to at least try them. It is always a lot of fun to see what the new month's box has inside!