Rateyourmusic Reviews

Voted Poor (3/5)

7 Votes

6 Reviews

Vote Now

Transforming My Musical Journey: A Tribute to RYM

My experience with rateyourmusic.com has been nothing short of transformative. Having immersed myself in the world of music from 2003 to 2008, this platform became my sanctuary, offering a wealth of information and a vibrant community of fellow music enthusiasts. Unfortunately, my journey took an unexpected turn when my account was banned in 2008 due to a disagreement regarding sources. Despite pouring my heart and soul into contributing over 50,000 releases, correcting information, and enriching the database with detailed tracklists, I was met with what I can only describe as cronyism. The ban led me to seek refuge in Discogs, yet the transition was not without its challenges. While Discogs provided a new home, I found myself missing the curated ratings and sleek artist pages that RYM had perfected. Nostalgia often hits me as I re-download albums, wishing I could effortlessly access my meticulously curated ratings and reviews. Reflecting on my departure, I couldn't help but notice a trend of other valued contributors facing similar fates. It begs the question: why penalize those who are the very backbone of the platform? The sense of community and camaraderie that once defined RYM seemed overshadowed by inexplicable decisions. Despite the setback, my musical journey perseveres, enriched by the memories and discoveries from my time on RYM. To the team behind RYM, I implore you to remember the essence of what made your platform special - the passion and dedication of your users. Let us continue to harmonize our love for music and create a space where all voices are valued and celebrated.

A Horrible Disappointment

My assessment for rateyourmusic.com I might been a consumer of RYM for over a decade. However I simply can't stand it anymore. If I have been score the RYM of 2014, I would give it a 3 or 4. However at present, in 2024, it is devolved considerably into a really ugly and oppressive place, worthy of the worst doable score. And it's because the mods and admins have turn out to be unbearably strict and authoritarian. They hold including extra draconian guidelines that suck all of the life, selection, and individuality out of the positioning. Rock music might be the preferred style on RYM. However mockingly, the anal-retentive and humorless homeowners & mods are the least "rock and roll" folks on the planet. There was numerous cool and attention-grabbing contributors to the positioning. Individuals who had enjoyable and fascinating profiles, compelling and/or humorous evaluations, and uniquely thought-provoking lists. However now virtually all these persons are gone (and their lists & evaluations deleted). A lot of them have been banned for petty and arbitrary causes. And the remainder of them have voluntarily deserted their accounts after years of accelerating harassment from the fascistic moderation crew. Lets take a look at the assessment system, for instance. Ostensibly, anybody can be a part of RYM and write their very own private evaluations of any album, single, or movie. However over time, virtually all the greatest and most attention-grabbing evaluations would get unpublished or deleted. It's because the principles for what counts as an "acceptable" assessment on RYM grew to become ridiculously strict and inflexible. It is actually to the purpose the place probably the most well-known skilled rock critics of the 70s/80s/90s (Lester Bangs, JD Considine, David Marsh, and so forth) wouldn't have their evaluations accepted on RYM. An excessive amount of creativity and individuality. No, cannot have that! So as to be acceptable to RYM requirements, your assessment should match inside probably the most bland, sterile, cookie-cutter field. It is gotten so dangerous that if you happen to take a look at the RYM evaluations which are nonetheless seen, you will see that the majority of them may have been written by Chat GPT. It is pathetic. However no matter you do, do not you dare complain. It's because the principle proprietor (Sharifi) and his moderation crew are probably the most petty and vindictive folks on the web. Should you complain, they retaliate and bully you. They assault your character. They gaslight you. They continually accuse you of "dangerous religion" only for wanting the liberty to be your self. Or they ship their associates to troll your web page with abusive feedback. Then they punish you with warnings or suspensions based mostly fully on their false allegations. It is disgusting and inexcusable. Message to the homeowners: Cease banning probably the most attention-grabbing members. Cease unpublishing probably the most attention-grabbing evaluations. Cease deleting probably the most attention-grabbing lists. Cease making an attempt to drive your complete neighborhood into cookie-cutter mini variations of yourselves. Let a range of kinds and opinions flourish, as an alternative of suppressing them. Then, and solely then, you would possibly ultimately have a web site that is price coming again to.

Unveiling Musical Gems: A Decade-Long Journey on RateYourMusic

Embarking on a digital odyssey back in 2008, my discovery of RateYourMusic was nothing short of serendipitous. Over the years, this platform has evolved, but its core essence of musical and cinematic abundance remains steadfast. From obscure indie bands to blockbuster hits, the sheer wealth of content is awe-inspiring. What truly sets RateYourMusic apart is its vibrant community-driven ecosystem. Diving into user reviews feels like unraveling personal musings, unearthing hidden gems, and stumbling upon impassioned debates. The platform's expansive lists offer curated selections that cater to every conceivable taste, serving as a compass in the vast sea of artistic expression. Furthermore, the forums serve as a melting pot of diverse voices, fostering discussions that range from nostalgia-inducing classics to avant-garde experimental sounds. It's a haven where aficionados, novices, and enthusiasts converge, transcending geographical boundaries to bond over a shared love for music and movies. In essence, RateYourMusic isn't just a website; it's a sanctuary for seekers of sonic bliss and cinematic marvels. Its evolution mirrors the ever-changing landscape of artistry, yet its essence remains unwaveringly indispensable. As I continue my voyage through the eclectic realms of music and film, RateYourMusic stands as a beacon, guiding me toward undiscovered treasures that enrich my cultural tapestry.

Embracing Diverse Voices and Music Journeys

Revisiting the inspiring community at rateyourmusic.com has been a bittersweet experience. Over the years, I poured my heart and soul into sharing my music discoveries, only to find myself banned recently for expressing an unconventional viewpoint. My profile, a reflection of my musical odyssey, was adorned with personal touches that resonated with who I am. However, the platform's shift towards stifling dissenting voices left me reeling. A simple quote advocating for diversity of thought led to my exclusion. It pains me to witness the silencing of longstanding members whose passion once fueled the thriving community. The once-vibrant platform risks losing its essence in the pursuit of conformity. Let's hope for a return to embracing diverse voices and celebrating the unique music journeys that unite us all.

Community Passion Shines on rateyourmusic.com

When I first stumbled upon rateyourmusic.com, I was instantly struck by the sheer dedication and passion exuded by its community. The effort put forth by users to curate an extensive database of music is truly remarkable. It's heartwarming to see music enthusiasts come together to share their love for all genres and artists. However, as much as the community thrives, it's hard to ignore the website's outdated design and lack of moderation. The platform could greatly benefit from some refreshing updates to enhance user experience and streamline navigation. Additionally, a more stringent moderation system would help maintain quality and relevance across the site. Despite these shortcomings, the genuine love for music that radiates from rateyourmusic.com is undeniable. It's a place where music aficionados can connect, discover hidden gems, and engage in lively discussions. With some improvements, this platform has the potential to truly shine and become even more of a beloved hub for music lovers worldwide.

Discover Authentic Community & Support at Alternative Rating Platforms

I recently had a disheartening experience with rateyourmusic.com, where the lack of care from the administration overshadowed the vibrant user base. Despite investing significant time and effort into enriching the platform with content, I felt undervalued and disregarded by the owner and moderators. The owner, Hossein Sharifi's silence in the face of valid concerns was truly disappointing. It was disheartening to witness how disagreements with moderators or their acquaintances could lead to alienation, regardless of one's contributions or subscription status. This made me question the integrity of the site and its commitment to fostering a supportive and inclusive environment for users. My advice to fellow music enthusiasts is to explore alternative rating platforms that prioritize genuine community engagement and user support. Your passion for music deserves a platform that values your voice and contributions, where admins are responsive and respectful. Let's invest our time and energy into platforms that truly appreciate and empower their users.